Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Cricket/Stand-alone lists

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Whilst creating and editing cricket-related list articles, editors often encounter recurring questions on what lists are suitable for inclusion and what are not. WikiProject Cricket's participants have agreed to the following inclusion criteria as a result of discussion on its talk page and consensus reached from AfD discussions related to cricket lists. These criteria also fall within the WP:NLIST, WP:NOTSTATS and WP:LISTCRUFT policies and guidelines.

General
  • There must be a complete data of the lists altogether in independent and reliable sources, those lists should not be created as articles which have not collected in independent and reliable sources. For example- List of Bangladesh Premier League captains is acceptable as the list of captains have been included in multiple reliable stats websites. But such articles like List of Everest Premier League captains (note this is a red link) aren't acceptable, even if such lists are created by collecting list of captains from individual seasons.
  • The list topic should be discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources as per WP:NLIST.
  • The list of statistics should have context or explanation, statistics should be placed in tables to enhance readability, and articles with statistics should include explanatory text providing context with independent and reliable sources as per WP:NOTSTATS. Just copying from any stats websites can't meet the inclusion criteria.
Lists of individual and cricket team records
Lists of records, players and centuries/five-wicket hauls of tournaments
  • Only those records which are considered as significant records or achievements should be included for international or domestic tournaments, such as- Scoring a century or picking up a five-wicket haul.
  • The lists of statistics/records or players of international or domestic tournaments are suitable if the matches of the tournament have received official Test, ODI, T20I, first-class, List A or T20 status by the International Cricket Council (ICC). But there must be a source from which the data has been collected. If any list of tournaments' records and statistics is created by collecting the records altogether from the statistics section of the articles of individual tournaments' seasons, then it will not be acceptable.
  • The lists for statistics or records for short-lasting tournaments which have been only one season should not be included, because the statistics for that one season can be found on the main article of that season. For examples- List of National Cricket League Twenty20 records and List of Lanka Premier League records and statistics which were nominated for deletion and were closed as "delete" or "redirect" per the consensus reached through discussions.
List of centuries or five-wicket hauls on cricket grounds or by individual cricketers
  • Any list of centuries or five-wicket hauls on any cricket ground should only be created if it is enough prestigious for a player to score a century or to pick up a five-wicket haul on that ground.
  • For the list of centuries or five-wicket hauls on any cricket ground, the ground must have received substantial coverage for the centuries or five-wicket hauls at the ground.
  • Any list of centuries or five-wicket hauls by any cricketer is should only be created as a separate article if there is enough coverage about the centuries or five-wicket hauls by the cricketer. The members of WikiProject Cricket have agreed to consider 25 centuries and 15 five-wicket hauls as the cut-off for individual cricket centuries or five-wicket hauls, as it is presumed that there may be some coverage when any player scores 25 centuries or picks up 15 five-wicket hauls. But if there is not enough coverage despite meeting the cut-off, the article will fail the criteria. For example- List of international cricket centuries by Sachin Tendulkar meets the criteria as there is much coverage about the player's centuries.
  • As mentioned above in the general criteria, the articles with list of centuries or five-wicket hauls should also have explanatory text or summarised content providing context with independent and reliable sources in the lead section.