| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:1992 in the Czech Republic |
merge |
April 5
|
| Category:2000s Western film stubs |
Upmerge, category can be recreated when there are enough stubs for this category - we can use the template to do this quickly |
April 11
|
| Category:2010s Western film stubs |
Upmerge |
April 10
|
| Category:Aberwheeler |
delete both |
April 8
|
| Category:African Development |
Speedy rename (due to meeting critera & no objections raised within 48 hours) per rationale C2C ("A rename bringing a category into line with established naming conventions for that category tree") |
April 24
|
| Category:African-American essayists |
double upmerge as nominated |
April 26
|
| Category:African-American films |
keep but purge. As closer, I'm not qualified to do the purging, so someone else is going to have to pursue this. |
April 7
|
| Category:African-American science fiction writers |
upmerge as nominated |
April 28
|
| Category:Afrikaans phonology |
delete |
April 1
|
| Category:Akbar Khan Qureshi |
convert to article |
April 8
|
| Category:Alabama nonfiction |
merge to Category:Alabama culture |
April 10
|
| Category:Albums arranged by Donovan |
delete |
April 5
|
| Category:All knots |
speedy delete per WP:CSD#C1 as empty, without prejudice to re-creating it.
I have not been able to determine how the category came to be emptied while the discussion was underway, but once a category has been emptied it is removed from the attention of editors who might have found it through the articles, and thereby seen the link to this discussion. So even tho most editors commenting prefer merger, I can't count that as a valid consensus. If anyone finds out how the category was emptied, please leave a note on my talk page, and I will administer a WP:TROUTING to whoever emptied it |
April 15
|
| All Star Gaelic footballers |
Merge |
April 29
|
| All-Star hurlers by year |
Merge |
April 29
|
| Category:American Chicano novelists |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:American humor novelists |
merge as nominated |
April 28
|
| Category:American humor writers |
speedy merge per WP:C2E |
April 28
|
| American local politicians |
keep Category:Local political office-holders in the United States; delete Category:American local politicians |
April 24
|
| Category:American male writers |
no consensus |
April 25
|
| Category:American men novelists |
no consensus to merge, but I am going to rename this to Category:American male novelists as suggested so at least people can stop laughing at Wikipedia for that |
April 25
|
| Category:American romantic fictions writers |
withdrawn |
April 26
|
| Category:American women essayists |
upmerge as nominated |
April 26
|
| Category:American women novelists |
duplicate nomination: see Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2013 April 24#Category:American women novelists |
April 25
|
| Category:American women novelists |
The result, by a fairly large margin in both numbers and arguments, is in favor of merging the categories back together at Category:American novelists, while keeping the women novelists separate Category:American women novelists because it is a recognized field of study in the literature. {{All included}} and/or {{Distinguished subcategory}} should be kept on the latter so that this does not happen again. Can someone with AWB or a similar tool do this soon, given the frighteningly large amount of media coverage focused on these categories and related discussion? Thanks, |
April 24
|
| Category:American women screenwriters |
merge |
April 30
|
| Category:Ancient Macedonians who were executed |
rename using the second proposal. Although these will not match others in e.g. Category:Ancient Romans by death, there are other precedents e.g. Category:Executed Ancient Egyptian people and Category:Executed Byzantine people. – |
April 26
|
| Category:Angelina Jolie |
delete. – |
April 10
|
| Category:Animal cruelty |
rename to Category:Cruelty to animals to match the head article and to make it clearer who is being cruel to whom. There's no consensus for a greater change |
April 4
|
| Category:Apple Design Award winners |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:Argentine rugby union teams |
no consensus |
April 5
|
| Category:Arkansas Sports Hall of Fame inductees |
listify then delete |
April 27
|
| Category:Athletes from Ireland |
delete as the two remaining sub-cats are already in appropriate sub-cats of Category:Irish sportspeople. – |
April 22
|
| Category:Augusta State University |
keep. – |
April 26
|
| Category:Australian cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Australian transport-related lists |
rename. I'll also Speedy-nominate the outliers |
April 4
|
| Category:Avenues |
no consensus. |
April 29
|
| Avex Group artists categories |
Merge |
April 13
|
| Category:Aviation Hall of Fame of New Jersey inductees |
Delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Azerbaijani inhabited regions |
delete |
April 19
|
| Category:Bachelors |
delete. – |
April 26
|
| Category:Baltimore Colts (1953-1983) seasons |
keep (i.e. do not rename) |
April 10
|
| Category:Bangladeshi torture victims |
keep. None of the arguments against this category offered any plausible reason to delete this category, while keeping all the other sub-cats of Category:Torture victims by nationality. There may be a case for deleting Category:Torture victims and all its sub-categories (I didn't see one here, but maybe there is such a case) ... and if editors want to make that case, then there should be a group nomination so that all the categories can be considered together.
In the meantime, if some of the articles in this category are not torture victims, then that miscategorisation can be fixed in the usual way, by altering the categorisation of that particular article |
April 19
|
| Category:Bays of Cardiff |
delete |
April 5
|
| Category:BBC Audio Drama Award winners |
delete |
April 28
|
| Category:Beninese cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Birmingham Gay Pride |
delete |
April 17
|
| Category:Birmingham Gay Village |
merge |
April 21
|
| Category:Bosnia and Herzegovina cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Brad Pitt |
delete. – |
April 10
|
| Category:Breakfast beverages |
delete |
April 8
|
| Category:Breakfast foods |
delete |
April 10
|
| Category:British men novelists |
no consensus to delete, but I am going to rename it to Category:British male novelists, so at least people can stop laughing at Wikipedia for that |
April 25
|
| Category:Brumbies rugby union players |
rename. There are no other teams on Wikipedia named just Brumbies, and until there are, this rename is warranted |
April 7
|
| Category:Buffy comics titles |
merge |
April 30
|
| Category:Buildings and structures of the Arab Spring |
delete Category:Buildings and structures of the Arab Spring. The Libyan category had not been tagged, so cannot be deleted as a result of this discussion. Feel free to nominate it again without delay |
April 6
|
| Category:Burger King Whoppers players |
Speedy rename C2D |
April 1
|
| Category:Burials at the Willesden Jewish Cemetery |
speedy redirected |
April 7
|
| Category:Candidates in British Columbia provincial elections (2013) |
Delete |
April 23
|
| Category:Cartoon Network-related lists |
keep |
April 12
|
| Category:Cate Blanchett |
delete. Sub-cat was also deleted. – |
April 10
|
| Category:Cessnock geography stubs |
Keep |
April 11
|
| Category:Cheeses of Northern Ireland |
merge to Category:Northern Irish cheeses, which can be a subcategory of Category:British cheeses and Category:Irish cheeses |
April 13
|
| Category:Cheeses with Denomination of Origin |
rename to Category:Cheeses with designation of origin protected in the European Union |
April 14
|
| Category:Christian Bale |
Delete |
April 15
|
| Category:Cleveland Cuisine |
Delete |
April 23
|
| Category:Coal mining in Anglesey |
merge all to Category:Coal mining in Wales |
April 8
|
| Category:Coal mining in Cardiff |
delete (both categories have remained empty). |
April 8
|
| Category:Comparisons to Nazism and the Holocaust |
delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Computer law legislation |
rename to Category:Computing legislation. |
April 8
|
| Category:Connecticut Huskies of Honor |
delete |
April 18
|
| Category:Conscientiology |
delete |
April 18
|
| Category:County law enforcement agencies of the United States |
keep |
April 25
|
| Category:Cowboy halls of fame inductees |
Delete |
April 9
|
| Category:Criticism of feminism |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Cross and Circle games |
speedy rename per WP:C2C |
April 5
|
| Category:Cultural Sites on the UNESCO World Heritage Tentative List |
delete |
April 5
|
| Category:Czech Board Games games |
speedy delete per creator's request (WP:CSD#G7) |
April 5
|
| Category:Cœur de pirate |
delete following many precedents for such small categories. There is already a template which is sufficient for navigation. – |
April 22
|
| Category:De la Pole family |
 Relisted at 2013 MAY 27 CFD. |
April 23
|
| Category:Debbie Reynolds |
delete |
April 11
|
| Category:Democratic Action (Philippines) politicians |
Reame |
April 9
|
| Category:Democratic Action (Philippines) politicians |
relisted at CFD 2013 April 9 |
April 1
|
| Category:Departments of the University of Manchester |
keep. |
April 27
|
| Category:Dungog Shire geography stubs |
Keep |
April 11
|
| Category:Edmonton Drillers |
delete per WP:OC#SHAREDNAMES. The Edmonton Drillers is a disambiguation page, and these category titles should also be dismabiguation pages, using {{category ambiguous}} |
April 1
|
| Category:Egyptian cheeses |
speedy keep,; nomination supported by nobody, and withdrawn by nominator |
April 13
|
| Category:Emirati cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Episcopal dioceses of the United States |
I'm going to merge both categories into a new Category:Dioceses of the Episcopal Church. Then users can create subcategories as desired, as discussed below. |
April 25
|
| Category:Equestrian commanders of vexillationes |
Keep |
April 24
|
| Category:Estoril Open |
rename |
April 28
|
| Category:Estuaries of Anglesey |
upmerge to Estuaries of Wales, plus "Coast of Foo" if not in a more specific sub-cat of it. I do not see a reason to reverse other changes, as the editor appeared to generally add other appropriate categories rather than remove them. – |
April 7
|
| Category:Estuaries of Cardiff |
merge to appropriate parents. – |
April 5
|
| Category:Executed collaborators with Nazi Germany |
rename per nominator |
April 20
|
| Category:Fashion albums |
rename as nominated |
April 13
|
| Category:Fede Alvarez |
procedural close: there is no such category.
I think that the nominator may have intended to nominate Template:Fede Alvarez, which should be listed at WP:TFD |
April 29
|
| Category:Fictional Druids |
rename |
April 5
|
| Category:Fictional left-handed people |
Delete |
April 3
|
| Category:Fictional sorcerers |
no consensus; it sounds like there may be some support for merging Category:Fictional sorcerers to Category:Fictional wizards and Category:Fictional sorceresses to Category:Fictional witches, or something similar. This can be pursued in a new nomination. |
April 30
|
| Category:Films directed by Angelina Jolie |
keep |
April 18
|
| Category:Films produced by Angelina Jolie |
delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Films produced by Cate Blanchett |
delete. – |
April 10
|
| Category:Films refused classification by the British Board of Film Classification |
Delete |
April 15
|
| Category:Forester stubs |
withdrawn |
April 11
|
| Category:Former trade unions |
rename |
April 4
|
| Category:Formula One magazines |
Delete |
April 24
|
| Category:Gangnam Style |
keep |
April 24
|
| Category:Gay culture in Liverpool |
merge |
April 21
|
| Category:Gay culture in London |
merge |
April 21
|
| Category:General law reviews |
rename |
April 12
|
| Category:Geocaching in the United Kingdom |
delete |
April 4
|
| Category:Georgian people executed by the Soviet Union |
Merge |
April 13
|
| Category:GLAM Ambassadors |
Speedy rename C2C |
April 16
|
| Category:Gloucester Shire geography stubs |
Keep |
April 11
|
| Category:Gold Coast Giants/Seagulls/Chargers |
rename all |
April 18
|
| Category:Golden Gloves champions |
delete |
April 21
|
| Category:Golden Ticket Award for Best New Ride |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:GQ Award winners |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:Great Lakes Council geography stubs |
Keep |
April 10
|
| Category:Groups of the United States |
rename to Category:Groups (military unit) of the United States. |
April 12
|
| Category:H2 symmetry group |
rename to Category:Redirects from H2 symmetries. – |
April 1
|
| Category:Heads of State of Israel |
keep |
April 10
|
| Category:Health issues in pregnancy |
do not merge |
April 14
|
| Category:Hey Arnold! characters |
delete |
April 12
|
| Highways |
withdrawn. – |
April 23
|
| Category:Historical figures portrayed in Deadwood (TV series) |
delete |
April 20
|
| Category:History of Quetta |
Rename |
April 22
|
| Category:Hobbies in Wales |
Delete |
April 7
|
| Category:Honorary Fellows of The Institute of IT Professionals |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:Human pregnancy and birth |
delete |
April 14
|
| Category:Humble Indie Bundle games |
rename |
April 3
|
| Category:Images of video covers |
merge Category:Video covers to Category:Images of video covers. |
April 3
|
| Category:Imperial Roman senators |
Rename to Category:Senators of the Roman Empire; other categories can be created as needed |
April 29
|
| Category:Instruments used in Hindu worship |
delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Inter-county football competitions |
merge |
April 19
|
| Category:James Madison Award Recipients |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:Japanese armour |
Keep |
April 25
|
| Category:Jeans enthusiasts |
delete. Closing early per WP:SNOW |
April 2
|
| Category:Jenko Award laureates |
Delete |
April 27
|
| Kerry Gaelic footballers by club |
Rename all |
April 18
|
| Category:Kurdish inhabited regions |
delete |
April 21
|
| Category:Leaders of counties in Iowa |
rename. The process here was far from ideal. The nominator's actions almost got me to invalidate the discussion and set it all back on principle. But the consensus is actually favoring the new, more specific form, so the change is going ahead |
April 19
|
| Category:Lingerie Football League |
Rename |
April 25
|
| Category:Lists of bus routes in England |
merge as nominated |
April 3
|
| Category:Lists of characters in Magic: The Gathering |
Delete |
April 24
|
| Category:Literary dunces |
listify and delete |
April 8
|
| Category:Literature by theme |
Rename |
April 1
|
| Category:Lithuania school stubs |
upmerge to Category:European school stubs and Category:Lithuania stubs; keep template |
April 12
|
| Category:Local Hero Award winners |
delete |
April 28
|
| Category:Locomotive Dump Sites |
delete |
April 11
|
| Category:Los Angeles Museum of the Holocaust Award recipients |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:Maitland geography stubs |
Keep |
April 10
|
| Category:Major gods |
delete. Closing early per WP:SNOW |
April 4
|
| Category:Malayalam-language writers |
merge Category:Malayalam writers to Category:Malayalam-language writers |
April 14
|
| Category:Maltese cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Manocan bridge players |
Rename |
April 23
|
| Category:Materials involved in Hinduism |
listify and delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Mauritanian cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:MewithoutYou |
delete |
April 10
|
| Category:Mexican chocolate |
merge Category:Chocolate para mesa to Category:Mexican chocolate |
April 13
|
| Category:Michigan Motor Sports Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
April 18
|
| Category:Military aircraft of the Cold War |
delete |
April 2
|
| Category:Mirza title stubs |
merge to Category:Asian royalty stubs |
April 12
|
| Category:Modern surface-to-air missiles of the United Kingdom |
Relisted at 2013 MAY 27 CFD |
April 30
|
| Category:Music published by Oops Publishing |
rename |
April 7
|
| Category:Muslim communities |
delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Muswellbrook Shire geography stubs |
Keep |
April 11
|
| Category:Mystery films by country |
there was a consensus to keep this category. But even if there had been a consensus to delete it, the discussion would still have closed as "keep" because this is a container category and there is reason to orphan its sub-categories |
April 4
|
| Category:Named cranes |
rename to Category:Individual cranes (machines) |
April 6
|
| Category:National Collegiate Basketball Hall of Fame inductees |
delete; no need to listify, since a list already exists.
Slightly more editors preferred keeping the category, but WP:NOTAVOTE. The long-standing wider consensus at WP:OC#AWARD is that award categories are reserved for only a small number of exceptionally significant awards. This may be the highest hall of fame honor which a college player can get for their college achievements, but it remains a subset of the wider sport of basketball |
April 17
|
| Category:National Register of Historic Places listings in Imperial County, California |
rename |
April 6
|
| Category:NCAA women's ice hockey seasons with Patty Kazmaier Award winner |
Delete |
April 14
|
| Category:New England awards |
keep Category:PEN New England awards; rename Category:New England awards to Category:Culture of New England. |
April 27
|
| Category:New Zealand House of Representatives accredited news organisations |
Delete |
April 23
|
| Category:New Zealand organisations with coats of arms |
Delete |
April 7
|
| Category:Newcastle, New South Wales geography stubs |
Keep |
April 10
|
| Category:NHL All-Star Game broadcasters |
delete. |
April 3
|
| Category:Nicaraguan cheeses |
keep |
April 13
|
| Category:Northern Irish cheeses |
keep (and see discussion immediately below) |
April 13
|
| Category:Norwegian Broadcasting Corporation television programmes |
rename |
April 18
|
| Category:Number-one singles in Indonesia |
Delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Omniscience |
Delete. I forcast a very heavy snow |
April 29
|
| Category:Organ transplantation journals |
withdrawn |
April 17
|
| Category:Oued Ed-Dahab-Lagouira geography stubs |
merge to Category:Western Sahara geography stubs. |
April 12
|
| Outdoor recreation in Wales subcategories |
Delete |
April 9
|
| Category:Pacific-12 Conference Men's Basketball Hall of Honor inductees |
delete both. The consensus is that this is not the highest level of award available to basketball players |
April 17
|
| Category:Pages using Template Convert |
delete G7 The consensus at the template's talk page is to return to the slightly less convenient but vastly less problematic method of tracking subtemplates. This goes for the category's subpages as well |
April 9
|
| Category:Passeridae stubs |
upmerge to Category:Passeroidea stubs |
April 12
|
| patience games |
rename to Category:Double deck solitaire card games and Category:Forty Thieves solitaire card games. |
April 13
|
| Category:People from Clear Spring, Maryland |
merge both |
April 18
|
| Category:People from Coconut Creek, Florida |
Merge |
April 15
|
| Category:People from Cooper City, Florida |
Merge |
April 15
|
| Category:People from Decherd, Tennessee |
Merge |
April 15
|
| Category:People from Eminence, Kentucky |
Merge |
April 16
|
| Category:People from Gosnold, Massachusetts |
merge |
April 28
|
| Category:People from Graysville, Tennessee |
merge |
April 17
|
| Category:People from Joy, Illinois |
merge both |
April 18
|
| Category:People from Manchester, Kentucky |
Merge |
April 23
|
| Category:People from Montgomery Township, Montgomery County, Pennsylvania |
Merge |
April 14
|
| Category:People from Needles, California |
Keep |
April 23
|
| Category:People from Pineville, Kentucky |
merge |
April 17
|
| Category:People from the West Midlands (county) executed by hanging |
no consensus to delete |
April 1
|
| Category:People from Wagram, North Carolina |
merge and redirect |
April 2
|
| Category:People from Zamboanga Peninsula |
keep; nominator apparently overlooked Category:People by region in the Philippines |
April 27
|
| Category:Persona |
rename. |
April 20
|
| Category:Phoenix songs |
Rename |
April 1
|
| Category:Places in South Africa with White plurality populations |
Delete |
April 29
|
| Category:Places in the United Kingdom |
delete all |
April 8
|
| Category:Plant articles with English titles |
delete |
April 17
|
| Category:Plant common names in New Zealand |
Relisted at 2013 MAY 27 CFD. |
April 27
|
| Category:Players of Canadian football killed in accidents |
delete |
April 8
|
| Category:Pocitos, Montevideo |
No rename |
April 7
|
| Category:Politics of Quetta |
nomination withdrawn |
April 22
|
| Category:Populated places in Chilcotin (region) |
rename. |
April 23
|
| Category:Port Stephens Council geography stubs |
Keep |
April 10
|
| Category:Proposed provinces of Thailand |
delete |
April 19
|
| Category:Psy (entertainer) |
Rename |
April 22
|
| Category:Purefoods Tender Juicy Giants players |
Speedy rename C2D |
April 1
|
| Category:Rape victim advocates |
Everyone agrees a rename is appropriate, but there's not much consensus on what name to use. There are a number of options were possible here, but I have selected Category:Sexual abuse victims activists simply because it is most consistent with Category:Sexual abuse victims advocacy and the entire Category:Activists tree. If users decide a different name is preferable, we can have another CFD about it. |
April 1
|
| Category:Recipients of the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade |
Delete |
April 15
|
| Category:Retcon films |
rename |
April 21
|
| Category:Revolution landmarks |
Delete |
April 13
|
| Category:Robot characters in video games |
do not rename |
April 17
|
| Category:Rollins College Wikipedians |
Delete |
April 25
|
| Category:Rudbar-e Jonubi County geography stubs |
withdrawn |
April 11
|
| Category:Russ Freeman albums |
Speedy rename C2D |
April 11
|
| Scenic routes |
Rename/Merge |
April 23
|
| Category:Science fiction Westerns |
No rename |
April 23
|
| Category:Scottish English surnames |
merge to Category:Surnames of Scottish origin |
April 15
|
| Category:Self-published writers |
delete |
April 12
|
| Category:Serbian war crimes in World War II |
rename per nominator |
April 1
|
| Category:Settlements with Regis suffix |
delete. If anyone wants to create a list, the entries can be selected from Regis (place) and List of place names with royal patronage in the United Kingdom. But do consider whether any such list would meet WP:LISTN |
April 22
|
| Category:Sharia |
no consensus |
April 4
|
| Category:Singleton Shire geography stubs |
Keep |
April 10
|
| Category:Smithsonian Folklife Festival participants |
delete |
April 17
|
| Category:Songs produced by Roger McGough |
delete |
April 3
|
| Category:Songs written by Anthony Santos |
Rename |
April 25
|
| Category:South Australian of the Year Award winners |
listify and delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Spaghetti Westerns |
Speedy rename C2C |
April 29
|
| Category:Special elections to the 114th United States Congress |
speedy delete per WP:CSD#C1 |
April 2
|
| Category:Sport in Portarlington, County Laois |
rename |
April 19
|
| Category:Sportspeople from Fingal |
keep |
April 4
|
| Sportspeople from Irish suburbs and towns |
speedy merge per WP:CSD#G7, since the category creator supports merger |
April 12
|
| Category:States of the Western United States |
Delete |
April 13
|
| Category:Stormers rugby union players |
rename to Category:Stormers (rugby union) players. There's general support for rugby union being added, but no clear directed on the parentheses. I decided to add them to match a lot (though not remotely all) of the similar categories |
April 7
|
| Category:Subjects taught in medical school |
delete |
April 22
|
| Category:Super Rugby squads |
speedy rename to Category:Super Rugby team navigational boxes. WP:C2C per convention of Category:Navigational boxes |
April 4
|
| Category:Television personalities |
No split |
April 29
|
| Category:Television towers in Japan |
rename all per nominator |
April 5
|
| Category:Territories and dependencies of Mauritius |
rename as nominated. The article has remained stable at Outer islands of Mauritius for several weeks now. No one has presented any good arguments in this case why the category should not match the article name (as is standard practice). |
April 1
|
| Category:Texas Pacific Group companies |
merge |
April 14
|
| Category:The Heart Network |
rename |
April 6
|
| The Holocaust in Yugoslavia |
merge. I will do this merger manually, as some of the other head categories also look appropriate in some cases. – |
April 5
|
| Category:Tityridae stubs |
Delete |
April 11
|
| Category:Tom and Jerry cartoons |
rename |
April 14
|
| Category:Towns and villages in India |
delete |
April 28
|
| Category:Transgender by region |
rename |
April 17
|
| Category:Transgender in non-western cultures |
split |
April 17
|
| Category:UCC footballers |
rename |
April 18
|
| Category:Ukrainian Armenians |
no consensus. We have two healthy category trees here, and we might need to look at the roots rather than the branches |
April 2
|
| Category:United Kingdom metro stations |
rename |
April 4
|
| Category:United Kingdom tram stops |
rename to Category:Tram stops in the United Kingdom |
April 4
|
| Category:United States proposed federal legislation of the 113th Congress |
merge to Category:United States proposed federal legislation and Category:113th United States Congress. |
April 4
|
| Category:University of Missouri Intercollegiate Hall of Fame Inductees |
delete. No need to listify, because a list already exists at List of University of Missouri Intercollegiate Athletics Hall of Fame Inductees |
April 15
|
| Category:Upper Hunter Shire geography stubs |
Keep |
April 11
|
| Category:Uruguayan people of African-American descent |
merge to appropriate Category:FOOian people of American descent categories |
April 30
|
| Category:US college sports venues |
upmerge, but to all parents.
There is a clear consensus that these categories are too narrow, and that they fail WP:SMALLCAT. However the discussion did not note that this would remove the articles from their other parent categories: e.g. Category:Auburn Tigers baseball venues is also a subcat of Category:Auburn Tigers baseball, Category:College baseball venues by team in the United States, Category:Baseball venues in Alabama, and Category:Auburn Tigers sports venues ... so a multiple upmerge is needed.
There are 4 other sub-categories of Category:College baseball venues by team in the United States. If editors want to nominate any of them for merger, please can they check whether multiple merge targets are needed? |
April 5
|
| Category:User poetry |
Delete |
April 16
|
| Category:Venezuelan bus drivers |
delete |
April 7
|
| Category:Vilnius geography stubs |
delete |
April 11
|
| Category:Visitor attractions (and its subcategories) |
keep. – |
April 1
|
| Category:Visitor attractions in Craighead County, Arkansas |
delete |
April 30
|
| Category:War crimes in former Yugoslavia |
Rename to Category:War crimes in the Yugoslav Wars |
April 16
|
| Category:Washington (state) musician stubs |
merge per nonminator |
April 15
|
| Western (genre) films |
Rename all |
April 26
|
| Category:Western (genre) films |
Procedural close, relist if Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2013 April 26#Western (genre) films is closed without consensus for renaming |
April 19
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories named after festivals |
no consensus. If we are going to overturn the past discussions where it was decided (1) that these categories may exist, and (2) that they should be hidden and labelled as administrative categories, we need a consensus that amounts to more than the limited agreement below. |
April 4
|
| Category:Wikipedia-Château de Versailles partnership |
rename |
April 17
|
| Category:Wikipedia-Norwegian Museum of Cultural History |
rename |
April 17
|
| Category:Wikipedians who read Isaac Asimov |
delete |
April 4
|
| Category:Wilson Administration personnel |
rename |
April 27
|
| Category:Women and death |
no consensus |
April 14
|
| Category:Women writers from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
merge |
April 30
|
| Women/Men or Female/Male as an adjective |
no consensus; in general, users seem open to some case-by-case fixes |
April 27
|
| Category:Works based on The Legend of Sword and Fairy |
merge to Category:The Legend of Sword and Fairy and Category:Xuanyuan Jian, as appropriate |
April 2
|
| Category:World War II Croatian concentration camps in former Yugoslavia |
rename. – |
April 1
|
| Years in New Zealand cricket |
no consensus to delete |
April 17
|
| Category:Youth Olympic Games host cities |
delete |
April 28
|
| Category:Yugoslav partisans |
merge as proposed, except using Category:Yugoslav Partisans members |
April 1
|
