| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:10¼ in gauge railways in England |
Keep (and do not delete redirects). No prejudice against a broader nom concerning fractions in category names, at editorial discretion. - |
March 3
|
| Category:11-M conspiracy theorists |
rename (non-admin closure) |
March 3
|
| Category:13th-century people from the Kingdom of Aragon |
no consensus to rename, but I find sufficient support to allow creation of new parent categories for subjects of the Crown. – |
March 14
|
| Category:15th-century Anglican church buildings |
merge. – |
March 16
|
| Category:15th-century Protestant martyrs |
rename |
March 24
|
| 1786 establishments in Bihar |
merge. I don't think anyone will object to me doing this on the grounds of WP:INVOLVED. – |
March 15
|
| Category:17th-century executions by Germany |
Rename to Option B, due to the Italy states issue, C2C, etc. No prejudice against a followup nom to propose splitting all the HRE cats to german states/italian states/etc. - |
March 2
|
| 1917 establishments in Bihar |
merge. – |
March 15
|
| 1940 and 1941 establishments in Bihar |
merge. – |
March 15
|
| Category:1969 establishments in Mysore State |
keep. – |
March 16
|
| 1983 establishments in India by state and union territory |
withdrawn. – |
March 15
|
| 1983_establishments_in_India_by_state_or_union_territory |
withdrawn. – |
March 18
|
| Category:2001 establishments in Andhra Prades |
speedy delete WP:G7.– |
March 20
|
| Category:2003 Texas redistricting |
delete |
March 19
|
| Category:Abandoned amusement parks in China |
merge. — |
March 4
|
| Category:Abandoned amusement parks |
merge to Category:Defunct amusement parks. — |
March 4
|
| Abbasid governors |
merge |
March 22
|
| Category:Acting Presidents of Myanmar |
rename |
March 30
|
| Category:Action films featuring female antagonists |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Actors from Achaia |
delete, doing with the contents as proposed |
March 8
|
| Category:Administrative territorial entities by type |
no consensus. Users are free to do what was suggested late in the discussion by Fayenatic london |
March 29
|
| Category:Ajax Orlando Prospects-related lists |
upmerge (non-admin closure) |
March 13
|
| Category:Aldrich family |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 18
|
| Category:All-Star Futures Game players |
delete |
March 12
|
| Category:Ambassadors of Canada to Taiwan |
split per option B. I have deleted Category:Ambassadors of Canada to Taiwan as empty. It can be re-created if it needs to be to fit into this adopted scheme |
March 31
|
| Category:American adult animated comic science fiction television series |
merge to all parents, i.e. Category:American adult animated comedy television series, Category:American adult animated science fiction television series and Category:American comic science fiction television series. – |
March 24
|
| Category:American adult animated science fantasy television series |
merge to all parents, i.e. Category:American adult animated fantasy television series, Category:American adult animated science fiction television series, Category:American animated science fantasy television series. – |
March 24
|
| Category:American adult animated space adventure television series |
merge to all parents, i.e. Category:American adult animated adventure television series, Category:American adult animated science fiction television series, Category:Animated space adventure television series. – |
March 24
|
| Category:American Burlesque performers |
rename. It is true that most of the categories were not tagged with Template:Cfr, but I am going to do something I hardly ever do and pull an IAR exception here, mainly because I cannot foresee any reasonable argument opposing the proposals |
March 23
|
| Category:American children's animated comic science fiction television series |
keep for now. There may be scope for renaming using "science fiction comedy" for clarification. – |
March 24
|
| Category:American people of Mexican descent |
keep |
March 28
|
| Category:American Samoan Roman Catholic bishops |
rename to Category:Roman Catholic bishops of Samoa–Pago Pago. The main concern seems to be applying "American Samoan" to these articles. This resolves that problem. (I'm using the style "Samoa–Pago Pago" to match the article Roman Catholic Diocese of Samoa–Pago Pago.) |
March 18
|
| American stations with a three-letter call sign |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:American writers born in the USSR |
delete, merging contents (as appropriate) to Category:Soviet emigrants to the United States |
March 7
|
| Ancient Greeks in Macedon |
Merge/Delete - |
March 19
|
| Category:Angiosperm incertae sedis |
alt rename as follows: |
March 12
|
| Category:Anglican archbishops by diocese in Ireland |
rename to Category:Anglican archbishops by province in Ireland |
March 1
|
| Category:Anglican bishop categories |
rename. There was not enough discussion about whether Category:Bishops of Australia/Category:Anglican bishops of Australia should be deleted, so if users want to pursue this, a new nomination for Category:Anglican bishops of Australia should be allowed |
March 4
|
| Category:Anglican bishops by diocese in Ireland |
rename to Category:Church of Ireland bishops by diocese |
March 2
|
| Category:Anglican priests |
Withdrawn by nominator. (non-admin closure) |
March 2
|
| Category:Animated science fantasy television series |
keep for now. If re-nominated, all the sub-cats should also be listed, each with specific multiple merge targets. – |
March 24
|
| Category:Anti-Catholic propagandists |
split to Category:Critics of the Catholic Church and Category:Anti-Catholic activists. – |
March 21
|
| Anti-Catholicism by country |
merge |
March 25
|
| Category:Archbishops of Mexico |
rename |
March 21
|
| Category:Archbishops of Nigeria |
rename to Category:Primates of the Church of Nigeria |
March 1
|
| Category:Archbishops of Salzburg |
merge |
March 21
|
| Category:Archbishops of Santo Domingo |
rename |
March 23
|
| Category:Armenian-controlled territories surrounding Nagorno-Karabakh |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Articles of Confederation |
delete |
March 8
|
| Category:Ashes to Ashes (TV series) user templates |
speedy rename. – |
March 23
|
| Category:Asian-South African culture in Johannesburg |
delete |
March 6
|
| Category:Asian-South African culture |
merge to Category:Asian South African. That category would need to be nominated to be renamed |
March 6
|
| Category:Assistant Bishops of Mount Kilimanjaro |
merge. The current common practice seems to be that assistant bishops are placed in the related bishops category. Discussions could be held elsewhere if users want to change this |
March 4
|
| Category:Austrian military personnel of World War II |
no consensus |
March 23
|
| Category:Azerbaijan rayon templates |
rename |
March 26
|
| Category:B'Tselem |
delete. — |
March 2
|
| Category:Barriers to critical thinking |
no consensus to delete as nominated, but if proposed there could be a consensus for a resolution of what to do with the contents |
March 28
|
| Category:Battle family |
delete |
March 18
|
| Category:Bennion–Eyring family |
delete. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Bielaski family |
delete |
March 29
|
| Category:Billboard Hot Latin Songs number-one singles |
delete |
March 20
|
| Birds |
remove Category:Birds from direct membership of Category:Dinosaurs, as this bypasses its existing proper categorisation via Category:Paravians which is already within Dinosaurs (albeit nine layers down). Dinosaurs is in turn already within Category:Reptiles (four layers down). Commendation to |
March 6
|
| Category:Bishops by country |
withdrawn by nominator |
March 17
|
| Category:Black Canary in other media |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Books of the Heian Period |
rename |
March 10
|
| Category:Brazilian Voodoo practitioners |
merge |
March 26
|
| Category:Broderip scholars |
convert to list (looks like it has already been done for the contents of the category). |
March 8
|
| Category:Brown priests |
there was not a clear consensus to do anything, but in the meantime I will rename it to Category:Brown priests (Nazism) for clarity. This is not to be interpreted as meaning there was a consensus to keep the category under that name |
March 27
|
| Category:Burial monuments and structures in Dominican Republic |
procedural close, nomination has been moved to WP:CFDS. (non-admin closure) |
March 10
|
| Category:Burials at Union Cemetery, (Steubenville, Ohio) |
rename to Category:Burials at Union Cemetery-Beatty Park. — |
March 2
|
| Category:Byzantine-era pagans |
rename as nominated. A follow-up nomination to consider exclusively a rename to Category:Late antique pagans could be started |
March 6
|
| Category:Caesarea (Israel) |
Rename to Category:Caesarea, Israel - |
March 25
|
| Category:Canadian labour movement |
merge |
March 10
|
| Category:Cancelled celebrities |
cancel delete |
March 13
|
| Category:Caribbean Series players |
delete. Category:Caribbean Series managers also exists but was not included in this nomination |
March 9
|
| Category:Catalan Muslims |
merge to Category:Spanish Muslims |
March 21
|
| Categorization of People |
(see below) |
March 6
|
| Centuries in Savafid Iran |
merge per Option A. Manual merges would be preferred, as the contents may be in suitable sub-cats of the targets already. I will put Category:People of Safavid Iran by century into Category:History of Safavid Iran; it should probably have a fresh nomination now. I am also putting the 16th-18th century categories for Iran, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Bahrain and Georgia into the that History category. – |
March 23
|
| Category:Ceremonial Voodoo languages |
delete |
March 27
|
| Category:Chan family |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Characters of the Slavic Cabinet Mythology |
delete for now. If an article gets written like be:Кабінетныя багі і духі беларускай міфалогіі then a justifiable catdhory be re-created easily enough. – |
March 19
|
| Category:Children of George VI |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Children of Louis XIII of France |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Children of Morgan le Fay |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Children of Nizam al-Mulk |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Children of Thutmose II |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Children's animated adventure television series |
keep. – |
March 24
|
| Category:Chilean marxists |
delete as duplicate of Category:Chilean Marxists |
March 9
|
| Category:Christianity and atheism |
merge |
March 27
|
| Category:City nicknames by city name |
Rename both - (Category:Lists of city nicknames has been tagged for renaming for 10 days as well.) - |
March 25
|
| Category:Civil Order of Savoy |
delete |
March 6
|
| Category:Color articles with suppressed CYMK data |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 6
|
| Category:Communes of Guyane |
rename |
March 13
|
| Category:Companions of the Star of Melanesia |
delete |
March 30
|
| Category:Congolese independence activists |
delete |
March 3
|
| Category:Constantiner Photography Award for an Israeli Artist recipients |
delete |
March 12
|
| Category:Contents |
keep. (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
| Category:Cousin couples |
rename; no consensus to delete. It's likely that the category will have to be monitored somewhat to ensure that biographies are not added to it. This is not an ideal situation |
March 24
|
| Category:Cousins |
rename to Category:Cousinship (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:COVID-19 vaccination programmes |
rename |
March 9
|
| Category:Croatian people of Bosnia and Herzegovina descent |
delete |
March 24
|
| Category:Cruel and Unusual Films films |
rename. I'll leave a redirect. 02:16, 16 March 2021 (UTC) |
March 5
|
| Category:Dames of the Order of Theresa |
delete |
March 11
|
| Category:Daniel Barenboim |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Deaths by dismemberment |
rename. I have changed the parent category from Category:Deaths by cause to Category:Amputations |
March 24
|
| Category:Deaths from cardiovascular disease |
delete as too routine a cause of death to be defining |
March 9
|
| Category:Defunct departments of the United Kingdom Government |
Rename - |
March 20
|
| Category:Detector dogs |
rename |
March 6
|
| Category:Dinosaurs of Chile |
Delete - Though it probably shouldn't have been completely emptied while discussion was ongoing, it sounds (from the discussion) like it had 3 articles and all 3 are currently categorized appropriately elsewhere in the tree. - |
March 20
|
| Category:Dolores O'Riordan |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:Dominica Roman Catholic bishops |
rename to Category:Roman Catholic bishops in Dominica. The sole content is now Category:20th-century Roman Catholic bishops in Dominica, so although there was support for Category:Roman Catholic bishops of Roseau, this seems to be the best option here. This is without prejudice to creating Category:Roman Catholic bishops of Roseau |
March 18
|
| Category:Earliest known manuscripts by language |
no consensus to delete. I suggest a fresh nomination to rename, perhaps to first/ oldest / earliest known written accounts of languages. – |
March 14
|
| Earthquakes by century, decade, and year before 1902 |
Procedural close. There is consensus among the CFD participants here for a dual merge of the year categories to decades and natural disasters, but to keep the decades and centuries categories. However, no action will be taken, because none of the category pages were tagged, so only CFD regulars will have seen this discussion, not editors/readers of the categories. @LaundryPizza03: try asking at WP:BOTREQ or |
March 12
|
| Category:Engish Anglican priests |
merge to Category:English Anglican priests, where it seems to more naturally fit as far as category names go |
March 2
|
| Category:English nonjuror bishops |
rename to Category: British nonjuror bishops. – |
March 18
|
| Establishments in Puducherry |
do not rename |
March 8
|
| Category:Ethnic issues in Japan |
rename |
March 19
|
| Category:Eurovision Song Contest by country |
delete, merging contents to "Music festivals in COUNTRY" categories |
March 29
|
| Category:Executed royalty of Macedonia (ancient kingdom) |
not renamed. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Execution |
merge and redirect as WP:OVERLAPCAT. I will put Category:Executed people into the other parent Category:Killings by type, although that one may also need reviewing. There may be scope for a category on summary executions, which would belong in Category:Extrajudicial killings by type. – |
March 25
|
| Category:Executive branch of Israel |
rename to Category:Executive branch of the government of Israel |
March 13
|
| Category:Executive branch of the Government of Afghanistan |
rename |
March 2
|
| Category:Executive branch of the Government of Pakistan |
rename |
March 13
|
| Category:Executive branch of the Government of Venezuela |
rename |
March 13
|
| Category:Executive branch of the Indian government |
rename |
March 12
|
| Category:Executive branch of the Moldovan government |
rename |
March 13
|
| Category:Executive branch of the Slovenian government |
rename. – |
March 14
|
| Category:Faculty by university or college and its subcategories |
no conclusion here, please see the discussion on the category talk page, as linked below. – |
March 22
|
| Famicom Tantei Club |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 15
|
| Category:Fandoms a better! |
has already been deleted |
March 20
|
| Category:Fantasy films by format |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Female urethra |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 16
|
| Category:Fictional hacker groups |
delete |
March 23
|
| Category:Film anthology series |
Rename - |
March 22
|
| Film scores by language |
merge |
March 13
|
| Category:Films directed by Wolfgang Becker |
Rename Category:Films directed by Wolfgang Becker to Category:Films directed by Wolfgang Becker (director, born 1954), per nom, to match article title. - |
March 5
|
| Category:Films edited by Robert Wise |
delete |
March 24
|
| Category:Films featuring Daisy Duck |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Films featuring Disney's Big Bad Wolf |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Films featuring Huey, Dewey, and Louie |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:First Shō clan |
it appears the category has already been speedily renamed to Category:First Shō dynasty after closure of the RM (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Former administrative divisions by continent |
rename/merge/delete as nominated |
March 2
|
| Former countries on the Italian Peninsula |
option B rename |
March 25
|
| Category:Gay businessmen |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Gay nobility |
merge |
March 21
|
| Category:Gay royalty |
merge |
March 10
|
| Category:Genji (series) |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Geographical naming agencies in Australasia |
Merge - |
March 17
|
| Category:Germanium chemistry |
merge |
March 10
|
| Category:Goldfinger (band) songs |
keep, note that Category:Songs by artist by default keeps subcategories with even only one article. (non-admin closure) |
March 13
|
| Category:Government agencies and parastatals of Kano State |
merge |
March 20
|
| Category:Government agencies and parastatals of Kwara State |
merge |
March 20
|
| Category:Grand Canyon, West region |
delete. — |
March 4
|
| Category:Grand Crosses of the National Order of San Lorenzo |
delete |
March 2
|
| Category:Grand Order of King Petar Krešimir IV recipients |
delete |
March 15
|
| Category:Harry Potter organizations |
rename (non-admin closure) |
March 2
|
| Category:Hatred |
split as nominated |
March 26
|
| Category:Henry Hope Reed Award Laureates |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:Heterostracan incertae sedis |
alt rename to Category:Heterostraci enigmatic taxa, Category:Bird enigmatic taxa and Category:Mammal enigmatic taxa. – |
March 12
|
| Category:Hinckley–Bitner family |
rename for now. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Hindu monasteries by country |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 10
|
| Category:Historic volcanic events |
merge |
March 12
|
| Category:Historical board games |
rename |
March 6
|
| Category:History of religion by period |
merge |
March 28
|
| Category:Horror adventure films |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Horror films featuring female antagonists |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:HuffPost bloggers |
no consensus |
March 25
|
| Category:Hungarian musicians from Cluj-Napoca |
merge the first one to Category:Musicians from Cluj-Napoca, as there is no consensus to remove them from that parent. Delete the other as empty. – |
March 13
|
| I-Kiribati non-people categories |
Rename. - |
March 2
|
| Category:Independent cities in the Philippines |
withdrawn (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Inkubus Sukkubus albums |
delete |
March 11
|
| Category:Inventions invented through American science and technology |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 2
|
| Category:Ion Television subchannel-only affiliates |
Merge (Do not have as separate) - |
March 17
|
| Iranian literature researchers |
merge |
March 21
|
| Category:Iranophobia in film |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Irish Anglican priests |
merge |
March 2
|
| Category:Items to be merged |
rename |
March 26
|
| Category:Iyer people |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Judges of the Uttarakhand High Court |
rename (non-admin closure) |
March 19
|
| Category:Judges who died in office |
delete. — |
March 2
|
| Category:Justice Society of America in other media |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Kansas City philanthropists |
rename to Category:Philanthropists from the Kansas City metropolitan area. Although the more experienced voices have suggested merger or deletion, not enough have weighed in to create a consensus in that direction. I have put this category into Category:Philanthropists from Missouri, so there is no need for its member articles also to be directly within that one. Perhaps another nomination might consider a split between that one and Philanthropists from Kansas City, Missouri, since Category:People from Kansas City, Missouri, by occupation has a more fully-developed hierarchy. – |
March 22
|
| Category:Kennedy family |
keep |
March 10
|
| Category:Kentucky colonels |
speedy delete. G4: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2016_March_22#Category:Kentucky_colonels |
March 9
|
| Category:Kentucky women in religion |
delete |
March 24
|
| Category:Khaganates |
merge |
March 21
|
| Kidnapped children |
keep Indian, Japanese and Swiss, now containing 3 or 4; merge the rest for now, as they still only contain 1 or 2 pages, so potential for growth has not been demonstrated.– |
March 19
|
| Category:Kimball–Snow–Woolley family |
delete. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Krishnan Medal recipients |
delete. – |
March 19
|
| Latter Day Saint denominations by belief |
merge. Although I was WP:INVOLVED, the consensus is unmistakable, and I assume no-one will object to me closing this CFD (against my own suggestion). – |
March 24
|
| Category:Law & Order (season 1) episodes |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 27
|
| Category:Left-wing populist parties |
delete. As noted, Category:Right-wing populist parties also exists and was not included in this nomination |
March 7
|
| Category:Legend of Legaia |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Legendary Christian saints |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Legion of Super-Heroes in other media |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Leonard Bloomfield Book Award authors |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Lists of mammals by continent |
not merged. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Lists of Members of the United States House of Representatives by seniority |
Rename - |
March 17
|
| Category:Living jazz pianists |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Lobo (DC Comics) in other media |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Locations near Mount Everest |
delete |
March 21
|
| Category:Macedonian archeologists |
merge & rename. The possible ambiguity over place of origin or area of study may not have come up before (cf. Category:Historians by geographical subject area / Category:Historians by nationality), and it would need a more comprehensive nomination to diverge from the current pattern. – |
March 3
|
| Category:Majorcan Muslims |
merge to Category:Spanish Muslims |
March 21
|
| Category:Male actors of English descent |
delete (and the one merge) |
March 22
|
| Category:Mayors of Paducah, Kentucky |
merge |
March 11
|
| Category:Mayors of Stillwater, Minnesota |
merge |
March 10
|
| Category:Media featuring female antagonists |
delete |
March 5
|
| Medieval Lutheran churches |
merge |
March 20
|
| Category:Members of the 32nd Alaska State Legislature |
delete. For related precedents, see Category talk:Legislators by term. – |
March 12
|
| Category:Members of the Bavarian Maximilian Order for Science and Art |
delete |
March 22
|
| Category:Members of the Board of Aldermen of the City of St. Louis |
rename |
March 10
|
| Category:Midrange apparat of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union |
delete. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Mike McGear songs |
keep Category:Songs written by Mike McGear as it now contains an article; delete Category:Mike McGear songs for now per precedents for categories containing only redirects, and not demonstrably useful per any of the rationales for WP:Categorizing redirects. – |
March 11
|
| MOS:SUFFIXDASH moves |
no consensus. I cannot amend WP:SUFFIXDASH for articles, but there is a lack of consensus about applying it to list categories, so I believe I must now insert an exception there for such categories |
March 20
|
| Category:Motor Toon Grand Prix |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Multilingual songs |
merge to Category:Macaronic songs. There is sufficient rough consensus here to merge to Category:Macaronic songs |
March 11
|
| Category:Murdered royalty of Macedonia (ancient kingdom) |
not renamed. — |
March 1
|
| Category:National symbols of the Republic of China |
rename. Note: I will also set up Category:National symbols of the Republic of China (1912–1949) (within Category:Republic of China (1912–1949)). – |
March 17
|
| Category:Neopaganism |
rename |
March 28
|
| Category:New Zealand apocalyptic films |
merge as nominated (non-admin closure) |
March 29
|
| Category:Novels by John Green (author) |
No Rename - |
March 17
|
| Category:Order of the Republic (Sierra Leone) |
delete |
March 6
|
| Orissa before 2011 |
option A rename |
March 9
|
| Category:Ottoman bishops |
rename to Category:Bishops in the Ottoman Empire |
March 20
|
| Category:Our Lady of Częstochowa churches in the United States |
delete |
March 21
|
| Oxidation states identified with non-Roman numerals |
rename |
March 4
|
| Category:Pages using invalid self-closed HTML tags |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 21
|
| Category:Pateros, Metro Manila |
rename. There seemed to be some confusion. The RM resulted in the article being moved to Pateros, but it was an RM from Aug 2020. This CFD gained some support and a confused comment, but no explicit opposition, so we'll go with renaming |
March 5
|
| Category:People associated with the London Business School |
rename. – |
March 18
|
| Category:People convicted of speeding |
delete |
March 1
|
| Category:People from Brambleton, Virginia |
merge |
March 8
|
| Category:People from Chonburi (city) |
merge |
March 10
|
| Category:People from Delphi |
keep. – |
March 18
|
| Category:People from Hurt, Virginia |
merge |
March 8
|
| Category:People from Kallieis |
merge. — |
March 4
|
| People from Lasithi |
merge. — |
March 1
|
| Category:People from Lemnos (regional unit) |
merge to Category:People from Lemnos. — |
March 1
|
| People from Lemnos |
merge. — |
March 1
|
| Category:People from Pateros, Metro Manila |
rename. There seemed to be some confusion. The RM resulted in the article being moved to Pateros, but it was an RM from Aug 2020. This CFD gained some support and some confused comments, but no explicit opposition, so we'll go with renaming |
March 5
|
| People from Phocis |
merge. — |
March 4
|
| People from Pieria (regional unit) |
merge |
March 5
|
| People from Preveza (regional unit) |
merge |
March 5
|
| Category:People from Puerto Ordaz |
rename to Category:People from Ciudad Guayana. — |
March 4
|
| People from Rhodes (regional unit) |
merge |
March 5
|
| People from Samos |
merge |
March 6
|
| People from Serres (regional unit) |
merge |
March 6
|
| People from Thesprotia |
merge |
March 6
|
| People from West Attica |
merge |
March 7
|
| People from Xanthi (regional unit) |
merge |
March 7
|
| Category:People involved in anti-Protestantism |
delete. (There are currently no organizations or events in these categories.) – |
March 20
|
| Category:People of Abkhazian descent |
keep |
March 27
|
| People of Chaoshanese descent |
merge/delete |
March 2
|
| People of Fuzhou and Hockchew descent |
delete/merge |
March 8
|
| People of Hainanese descent |
delete/merge |
March 9
|
| People of Hunanese descent |
delete/merge as nominated. – |
March 12
|
| People of Jiangsu descent |
delete/merge |
March 7
|
| People of Min descent |
merge (the "delete" votes mostly favour merging). – |
March 13
|
| People of Northern Han Chinese descent |
delete/merge as nominated. – |
March 12
|
| People of Peranakan descent |
rename to Category:Peranakan people in Malaysia and Category:Peranakan people in Singapore. This does for with the parent Category:Ethnic groups in Malaysia. – |
March 14
|
| Category:People who died in Auschwitz concentration camp |
do not rename |
March 30
|
| Category:People who died in office |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:People who purchased a nobility title |
delete. — |
March 4
|
| Category:People with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder |
delete |
March 24
|
| Category:People with cataracts |
delete |
March 26
|
| Category:Periodinanes |
keep. – |
March 7
|
| Category:Places related to the history of the Georgia Salzburgers |
delete |
March 15
|
| Category:Planters |
rename to Category:Plantation owners. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Played in the 2015 6 Nations |
delete |
March 30
|
| Politicians of Hakka descent |
no consensus |
March 10
|
| Category:Politicians who died in office |
delete. Note: I have created Category:Lists of politicians who died in office to hold lists but not biographies. – |
March 13
|
| Polygamous wives |
no consensus. This close is no bar to re-listing, especially as the initial discussion focussed on WP:G4 and WP:SMALLCAT, but the later contributions bring up WP:SUBJECTIVECAT which is worth a fresh discussion. – |
March 3
|
| Category:Pop EPs |
Rename per initial nom. Apparently Category:Pop albums was also later tagged - no consensus on that - but no prejudice on a separate follow-up nom on that. - |
March 18
|
| Category:Post-presidencies of Presidents of the United States (and all related categories) |
rename. I'm pushing the issue of deletion of some of the categories to the side, but this is without prejudice to a future deletion nomination |
March 26
|
| Category:Pratt–Romney family |
split as nominated. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Prehistoric synapsids |
restructure |
March 6
|
| Category:Preschool puppet series |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 7
|
| Category:Presidents of the United States who died while in office |
no consensus |
March 3
|
| Category:Protestant ecclesiastical decorations |
Merge Category:Protestant ecclesiastical decorations to Category:Ecclesiastical decorations - |
March 15
|
| Category:Protestant martyrs of the Middle Ages |
merge. – |
March 21
|
| Category:Radio programs by broadcast network |
rename |
March 10
|
| Category:Randolph Academy of the Performing Arts alumni |
rename |
March 29
|
| Category:Rapid human growth change in fiction |
merge to Category:Rapid human age change in fiction. |
March 20
|
| Category:Recipients of Hilal-e-Kashmir |
delete. (At the close, the category had already been deleted via G7.) |
March 9
|
| Category:Recipients of Tamgha-i-Jurat |
delete |
March 13
|
| Category:Recipients of the Albert Order |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Recipients of the Bavarian Order of Merit |
delete |
March 28
|
| Category:Recipients of the Bomber Command Clasp |
delete |
March 26
|
| Category:Recipients of the Bronze Cross of Zimbabwe |
delete. Clear consensus in favour of category deletion at this time |
March 24
|
| Category:Recipients of the Distinguished Flying Cross and two Bars (United Kingdom) |
merge. – |
March 16
|
| Category:Recipients of the Empress of India Medal |
delete. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Recipients of the Friedrich Order |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:Recipients of the Friedrich-August-Kreuz |
delete |
March 12
|
| Category:Recipients of the House and Merit Order of Peter Frederick Louis |
delete |
March 13
|
| Category:Recipients of the House Order of Hohenzollern |
delete. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Recipients of the House Order of the Wendish Crown |
delete |
March 24
|
| Category:Recipients of the José Reis Award of Scientific Divulgation |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:Recipients of the Ludwig Order |
delete |
March 2
|
| Category:Recipients of the Medal of Aeronautical Merit |
delete (category had already been deleted per G7) |
March 31
|
| Category:Recipients of the Medal of St. Hallvard |
delete |
March 29
|
| Category:Recipients of the Military Merit Order (Württemberg) |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Recipients of the Military Order of St. Henry |
delete. – |
March 14
|
| Category:Recipients of the Nansen medal for Outstanding Research |
delete |
March 30
|
| Category:Recipients of the National Order of Honour and Merit |
delete |
March 22
|
| Category:Recipients of the National Order of the Lion |
delete. — |
March 4
|
| Category:Recipients of the Nicolau Lobato Order |
delete |
March 25
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Duke Branimir |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Francisco de Miranda |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Glory (Ottoman Empire) |
delete |
March 23
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Menelik II |
delete |
March 20
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Philip the Magnanimous |
delete. — |
March 4
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Rio Branco |
delete |
March 28
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Roraima of Guyana |
delete |
March 27
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Black Star |
delete. – |
March 15
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Crown (Iran) |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Crown (Württemberg) |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Griffon (Mecklenburg) |
delete |
March 23
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Lion and the Sun |
delete |
March 29
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Pleiades (Iran) |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Red Eagle |
delete |
March 27
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Rokel |
delete. – |
March 14
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Roman Eagle |
delete |
March 20
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Rose |
delete |
March 11
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Southern Cross |
delete. I commend |
March 18
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Star of Ethiopia |
delete |
March 8
|
| Category:Recipients of the Red Cross Medal (Prussia) |
delete. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Recipients of the Royal Order of Kamehameha I |
delete. – |
March 16
|
| Category:Recipients of the Saxe-Ernestine House Order |
delete. — |
March 1
|
| Category:Recipients of the Saxon Merit Cross |
delete |
March 8
|
| Category:Recipients of the War Medal (Norway) |
delete |
March 31
|
| Category:Republicanism in Papua New Guinea |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:Riddim Ribbon |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Riddler in other media |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Right of asylum by country |
withdrawn (non-admin closure) |
March 16
|
| Category:Right of asylum law |
merge |
March 26
|
| Category:Roman Catholic archbishops by diocese and country |
rename to Category:Roman Catholic archbishops by country and diocese |
March 20
|
| Roman Catholic archbishops by diocese |
rename |
March 20
|
| Category:Roman Catholic archbishops by nationality |
not renamed |
March 16
|
| Category:Roman Catholic archbishops in Asia |
withdrawn (non-admin closure) |
March 20
|
| Roman Catholic archbishops in the United States, Canada, UK |
rename |
March 20
|
| Category:Roman Catholic priests in France |
delete |
March 8
|
| Category:Roud Folk Song Index songs |
delete |
March 12
|
| Category:Royal Guelphic Order |
delete |
March 25
|
| Category:Russian Empire Azerbaijani people |
merge to Category:People of the Russian Empire |
March 6
|
| Category:S.W.A.T. |
rename (non-admin closure) |
March 2
|
| Category:SB19 members |
delete |
March 11
|
| Category:School districts in Australia |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:Schools in Horseheads, New York |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:Scottish bishops |
no consensus |
March 16
|
| Category:Second Shō clan |
it appears the category has already been speedily renamed to Category:Second Shō dynasty after closure of the RM (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:Sertanejo artists |
rename |
March 24
|
| Category:Sheikhupura Cricket Association cricketers |
merge |
March 10
|
| Category:Sibling artists |
there is a consensus to keep the category, but there is no consensus on whether to keep it "as is" under its current name or to rename with a different scope. A follow-up nomination to rename/repurpose may be able to reach consensus on this issue |
March 29
|
| Siblings of national leaders |
delete |
March 31
|
| Category:Singaporean people of Chinese descent |
no consensus. There was a lot going on in this nomination, which may have contributed to the failure to reach consensus |
March 21
|
| Category:Singaporean people of Henghua descent |
no consensus. Note: this category has also been nominated for deletion within a group discussion at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2021_March_21#Category:Singaporean_people_of_Chinese_descent. – |
March 11
|
| Category:Singaporean people of Malay descent |
withdrawn. See this edit |
March 28
|
| Category:Sites using OpenStreetMap data |
Delete - |
March 18
|
| Category:Slogan lists |
rename |
March 30
|
| Category:Songs written by SZA (singer) |
rename |
March 19
|
| Category:South Park (season 24) episodes |
delete. (There was no content to merge to Category:South Park episodes.) |
March 6
|
| Category:Springfield College (Massachusetts) |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
March 25
|
| Squatting by country |
merge and purge. There are currently 4 articles for the Philippines; none of the others contain more than 3. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Chile |
purge and merge. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Ghana |
merge to Category:Squats per the main discussion above. The two locations are mentioned in the new article Squatting in Ghana, which will be moved instead to Category:Squatting by country. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Ireland |
merge. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Kazakhstan |
merge to Category:Squatting by country |
March 27
|
| Category:Squatting in Malaysia |
merge. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Nigeria |
split. Makoko has also been added, which may be appropriate, and Lagos, which IMHO is not. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Peru |
merge, moving San Juan de Miraflores, Villa María del Triunfo and Villa El Salvador to Category:Shanty towns in South America (per Squatting in Peru – but the reason for the category needs to be documented in each article). The main article goes instead to Category:Squatting by country. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in South Korea |
merge. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Sweden |
merge. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Squatting in Zimbabwe |
selective merge for now as there are fewer than five articles for which squatting is WP: DEFINING. No prejudice against re-creation when there are five or more. – |
March 17
|
| Category:Superhero films featuring female antagonists |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Superstars |
delete |
March 11
|
| Category:SZA (singer) songs |
rename |
March 19
|
| Category:Taxa named by Asghar Abdoli |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Taxa named by Joseph H. Wales |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:Taxa named by Kiavash Golzarianpour |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Taxa named by Roberta Barbieri |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Taxa named by Ronald Alan Fritzsche |
delete. — |
March 4
|
| Category:Television series about journalists |
merge. Users are free to purge the target category |
March 4
|
| Category:Television series about size change |
no consensus |
March 19
|
| Category:Television stations in the Tampa Bay Area |
Rename - |
March 15
|
| Template:ValdezCordovaAK-geo-stub and category |
speedy delete WP:G6. I found this via WP:CFDWM. For the record, 50 pages link to the Chugach stub template, and 34 pages to CopperRiver, so they are populating Category:Alaska geography stubs rather than the two separate categories that were approved here. – |
March 24
|
| Template:Vietnam-painter-stub |
keep |
March 6
|
| The entire Category:Cancer survivors tree |
delete |
March 21
|
| Things in Fez, Morocco |
Rename - |
March 19
|
| Category:Things named after Nikola Tesla |
delete |
March 31
|
| Travancore–Cochin |
rename to option A, mainly because the head article is still at Travancore–Cochin |
March 21
|
| Category:Trials in Great Britain |
rename to Category:Trials in the Kingdom of Great Britain. Re: the deletion issue that was raised, if anyone would like to nominate the category for deletion (or dispersion to Category:Trials in England and Category:Trials in Scotland), feel free to do so. |
March 9
|
| Category:Trumpists |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:UK MPs who died in office |
delete; content merged to Category:Politicians who died in office for now |
March 3
|
| Category:Ukrainian military formations |
no consensus. – |
March 21
|
| Category:Uncategorized articles needing expert attention |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 19
|
| Category:Unidentified vehicle accident victims |
delete. — |
March 3
|
| Category:University departments in Pakistan |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 12
|
| Category:Users who like cold weather |
delete |
March 6
|
| Utsul people |
delete |
March 15
|
| Category:Vaccination myths |
merge. – |
March 13
|
| Category:Valdez–Cordova Census Area, Alaska geography stubs |
split |
March 2
|
| Category:Vice Presidents of the United States (and all related categories) |
rename |
March 30
|
| Category:Victims of anti-Protestantism |
merge, and remove Category:Victims of anti-Catholic violence from Category:Victims of anti-Christian violence – those two should have "see also" links instead. – |
March 14
|
| Category:Video games based on Catwoman |
merge |
March 5
|
| Category:Video games featuring female antagonists |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Video games that support Vulkan (API) |
delete. – |
March 16
|
| Category:Voodoo deities |
no consensus. It may be useful to split the categories to new sub-cats for Haitian Vodou, so that it would be more clear which deities are not solely Haitian. (Deities in Haitian and another form of vodou would belong in both.) – |
March 24
|
| Category:Voodoo practitioners by nationality |
merge |
March 26
|
| Category:Voodoo researchers |
rename |
March 26
|
| Category:Wars by year subcategories |
rename per option A, i.e. as originally nominated. – |
March 19
|
| Category:Washington County high points |
Delete - |
March 14
|
| Category:Washington, D.C. sport-related lists |
No Consensus for whether it should be sport or sports. Adding category redirect to the red-linked one for now. - |
March 20
|
| Category:Web Summit Speaker |
delete |
March 26
|
| Category:Wellcome Book Prize |
no consensus |
March 25
|
| Category:Wells–Bennett–Grant family |
delete. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Wii and Wii U-only games |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 30
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories named after regions |
no consensus. In case any consensus emerges later to restore the deleted similar category for US regions, they can be found here.[1] But at the moment there is neither a clear rationale for deletion, nor an explanation of how these might be useful. – |
March 3
|
| Category:Wikipedia recent changes patrollers |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 23
|
| Category:Wikipedia toponymy |
rename, as I take the "keep" votes to be opposing deletion rather than committed to "toponymy". – |
March 28
|
| Category:Wikipedians against nationalism |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Wikipedians interested in number words |
Delete - |
March 14
|
| Category:Wikipedians interested in skiing |
Delete - |
March 14
|
| Category:Wikipedians interested in WWE |
merge Category:Wikipedians who like WWE to Category:Wikipedians interested in WWE |
March 6
|
| Category:Wikipedians who have access to Questia |
Delete - |
March 20
|
| Category:Wikipedians who like Ashes to Ashes (TV series) |
speedy rename. – |
March 23
|
| Category:Wikipedians who use VandalSniper |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Wikipedians who wish Ched would come back |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 17
|
| Category:Wikipedians with COVID-19 |
Delete - |
March 16
|
| WikiProject Gilgit-Baltistan |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 14
|
| WikiProject Islamabad |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 14
|
| WikiProject Khyber Pakhtunkhwa |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 14
|
| WikiProject Lahore |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 14
|
| Category:Winners of the Queen's Award for Voluntary Service |
delete. – |
March 19
|
| Category:Wives of Moses |
Delete - |
March 22
|
| Category:Women human rights defenders |
rename |
March 10
|
| Category:Woodruff family |
delete. – |
March 18
|
| Category:Works by Ishikawa Masamochi |
merge. This could be re-considered if more relevant articles are created |
March 6
|
| Category:Works of art commissioned by the police |
delete. — |
March 4
|
| Category:Worst United States Supreme Court decisions |
delete |
March 2
|
| Years in the War in Iraq (2013–2017) |
no consensus. It seems that everyone agrees that the current names are not appropriate, so a renomination may be the best thing to advise here |
March 20
|
| Category:Zionist activists |
no consensus, but this close is no bar to a further nomination covering relevant sub-cats. E.g. if it is to "purge and merge" Zionists to Zionist activists, then the sub-categories of Zionists by nationality etc would need to be brought into the nomination for renaming accordingly. This discussion is tending in that direction, but does not amount to a clear enough consensus to be implemented at the top and to justify speedy renaming of the subcats. – |
March 22
|
| Category:İstanbul-class destroyers |
delete (the category has already been emptied) (non-admin closure) |
March 30
|
