| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:16th century in the Democratic Republic of the Congo |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:1922 establishment in Hawaii |
Delete |
January 23
|
| Category:1981 Writers Guild of America strike |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:1988 Writers Guild of America strike |
delete. – |
January 26
|
| Category:2010s crime drama film stubs |
upmerge to Category:Crime drama film stubs and Category:2010s drama film stubs |
January 12
|
| Category:2011–2012 Bahraini uprising |
speedy rename per C2D to match Bahraini uprising (2011–present) |
January 31
|
| Category:2015 births |
defaulting to standard practice since there's no consensus to depart from it here: delete; can be created when there's something to do in it |
January 31
|
| Category:Academic journals published by libraries |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Academic journals published by the government |
Rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Academics by university in Europe |
Reverse merge. There is a clear consensus to merge, the question is in which direction. There is stronger support for the reverse merge. This close is consistent with the similar one below and specifically does not address the proposals for Category:Academic staff at foo university. I'm not sure if that becomes a split, which does not require a discussion here, or a followup rename. I'll let the participants decide on how to proceed with that decision |
January 21
|
| Category:Activities by jihadist organization |
rename, without prejudice to a future nomination to propose deleting any of them |
January 19
|
| Category:Airfields in the Middle East |
merge to Category:Airfields and Category:Aviation in the Middle East |
January 17
|
| Category:Alumni of Queen's Academy |
merge |
January 30
|
| Category:Ambystoma |
merge |
January 8
|
| Category:American al-Qaeda past members |
merge |
January 27
|
| Category:American cities in fiction |
rename |
January 6
|
| Category:American colonial women |
Opposed. And Speedily Renaming it to Category:Colonial American women per the discussion and other subcats of Category:American colonial people, and similarly its subcat Category:North American colonial women in warfare) to Category:Colonial American women in warfare. - |
January 2
|
| Category:American female songwriters |
no consensus since larger part of the discussion addressed the size of the category, not the rationale of nominator |
January 31
|
| Category:American jazz singer-songwriters |
delete. – |
January 26
|
| Category:American nondenominational Muslims |
Merge |
January 23
|
| Category:American Psychological Association academic journals |
do not split |
January 30
|
| American TV stations by channel number |
Listify |
January 7
|
| Category:Ancient Greek Versions with the Divine Name |
delete; merge content to Category:Septuagint manuscripts with the Divine Name |
January 14
|
| Anti-Xxx sentiment categories and some Persecution of ... categories |
No consensus - |
January 4
|
| Category:April sporting events |
keep without prejudice against a fresh nomination of the alternative proposal |
January 25
|
| Category:Aquarium inverts |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:AR platform |
rename to Category:AR-platform firearms |
January 13
|
| Category:Aragonese-speaking countries and territories |
Delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Arch Enemy songs |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Architects (British band) songs |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Areas controlled by the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Armstrong Atlantic State University alumni |
rename. Note that speedy rename nominations are listed at WP:CFDS. |
January 7
|
| Category:Articles for any kind of deletion |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Articles published in peer-reviewed literature |
rename to Category:Wikipedia articles published in peer-reviewed literature |
January 15
|
| Category:Artist collectives |
merge/rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Asturian-speaking countries and territories |
Delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Austerity Britain |
rename to Category:Austerity in the United Kingdom (1939–54). – |
January 20
|
| Category:Australian film actresses |
do not rename |
January 14
|
| Australian politicians |
Rename the first two sections. There does not appear to be consensus concerning "unsuccessful candidacy" categories. And due to that, and just the sense that the rest of the nom appears more to be brainstorming, I'm only closing based upon the first two sections. Feel free to re-nominate the rest (while presumably keeping this discussion in mind). - |
January 1
|
| Category:Austrian State Prize for European Literature winners |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Ayre (surname) |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Basque-speaking countries and territories |
Delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Bays of Bridgend County Borough |
delete; merge contents as proposed |
January 28
|
| Category:Benches |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:Best Music Video ― Female on Barbados Music Awards |
Delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Best Training Partner of NSDC STAR Scheme |
Delete |
January 16
|
| Category:Bridges across the River Gipping |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:British architecture |
reverse merge to Category:British architecture. There was consensus that we shouldn't have both categories. There was no consensus on what direction to merge. I selected to merge to Category:British architecture for two reasons: (1) "FOOian architecture" is the current standard for Category:Architecture by country. (2) Category:British architecture is older than Category:Architecture of the United Kingdom (2004 vs. 2008). This result is not to be regarded as a consensus for Category:British architecture over Category:Architecture of the United Kingdom, however, or for the "FOOian architecture" form over an "Architecture of FOO" form. Users should be free to propose a change to the format of this or the other by country categories without prejudice from this result. |
January 11
|
| Category:Buena Vista International films |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Western Australia by road & all subcategories |
no consensus |
January 17
|
| Category:Buildings and structures known by their street address |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Burials at priories |
Rename |
January 17
|
| Category:Burials by city |
make these into container categories; to implement this, rename delete Category:Burials by city to Category:Burials by city and place, and rename city categories to "Burials in Foo by place" if they have at least two subcategories, otherwise delete, and in either case purge any articles held at that level. If there is one subcategory (e.g. burials at a specific cemetery/church), move it up into appropriate parents. The country-by-city categories do not appear to need renaming, e.g. "Burials in Belgium by city and place" may be unnecessarily long, but this category level was not discussed here in detail so it may be nominated again |
January 17
|
| Category:Canadian cities in fiction |
rename |
January 6
|
| Category:Canadian football teams in Shreveport, Louisiana |
merge |
January 27
|
| Canadian TV stations by channel number |
Listify. @Bearcat and Bearcat:, @RevelationDirect and RevelationDirect:, @Sillyfolkboy and SFB:,@Peterkingiron and Peterkingiron:, @Mlaffs and Mlaffs: Lots of work to be done by the community to convert to lists |
January 7
|
| Category:Carcass songs |
speedy delete |
January 7
|
| Categories for Metalcore bands |
delete |
January 2
|
| Categories: Germany, Kosovo at the Olympics |
no consensus |
January 2
|
| Category:Catholic priests who spied for the Soviet Union |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Catholicism and Far-left politics |
delete; I note that Category:Eastern Orthodoxy and far-left politics is also a recent creation |
January 11
|
| Category:Cefnmeiriadog |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Charter schools in Delaware |
keep (do not delete) |
January 19
|
| Category:Chests |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:Christian politics |
rename |
January 12
|
| Category:Citation formats |
rename as proposed; don't keep redirects |
January 19
|
| Category:Civil rights movement during the Lyndon B. Johnson Administration |
UpMerge to Category:African-American Civil Rights Movement (1954–68). Feel free to also upmerge to Category:Presidency of Lyndon B. Johnson at editorial discretion. - |
January 4
|
| Category:Coalition of Urban and Metropolitan Universities |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Communist parties in Northern Ireland |
do not merge |
January 3
|
| Category:Communist parties in Transnistria |
merge |
January 7
|
| Category:Companies From Pennsylvania |
merge |
January 12
|
| Category:Converts to Protestantism from Anglicanism |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Cornish-speaking countries and territories |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Cosmopolitanism |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Counties of England in fiction |
speedy rename. – |
January 2
|
| Category:Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works License |
rename |
January 9
|
| Category:Cremations at Mount Thompson crematorium |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Criminals from the West Midlands (county) |
keep |
January 30
|
| Category:Dakar Rally winning vehicles |
Delete. It is possible that a category with a more specific purpose could exist, but this categhory is not defining. Feel free to create, with appropriate content a better defined category |
January 29
|
| Category:Damion Hall albums |
keep |
January 8
|
| Category:Dance-pop singles |
Withdrawn non-admin closure. Ten Pound Hammer • ( |
January 10
|
| Category:Darkest Hour songs |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Deaths by city in England |
Delete - I'm also deleting the then empty parent Category:Deaths by city in the United Kingdom. And upmerged the remaining 2 categories of its parent Category:Deaths by city and making that a category redirect to Category:Death by city. No prejudice against nominating Category:Death by city and its subcats. - |
January 18
|
| Category:Deaths from surgical complications |
Delete, strongest argument is that few, if any, are notable for having died form surgical complications, in most cases it is a trivium. |
January 8
|
| Category:Decentralized Software |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Defunct Roman Catholic dioceses |
rename. – |
January 26
|
| Category:Disbanded sports events |
Rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Disney's Big Hero 6 characters |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:DJ Tatana albums |
rename |
January 17
|
| Category:Dolby Surround 7.1 films |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Drug user |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Dutch Orangists |
Withdrawn |
January 5
|
| Category:Eastern Christianity |
keep |
January 16
|
| Category:Eastern Orthodoxy and far-left politics |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:ECO vehicles |
delete. – |
January 26
|
| Category:Economy of Ukraine by Region |
Merge |
January 20
|
| Category:Elsevier academic journals associated with learned societies |
merge to Category:Elsevier academic journals and Category:Academic journals associated with learned societies. |
January 26
|
| EU/Euratom treaty categorization corrected/consistent |
rename all. (NAC) |
January 3
|
| Category:European Federation of Centres of Research and Information on Sectarianism members |
delete |
January 24
|
| Executed American people (sub-sub) categories |
merge |
January 21
|
| Category:Faculty by university or college in the United Kingdom |
delete (nothing to merge following the result of the discussion immediately above). |
January 21
|
| Category:Faculty of the University of Oxford |
merge |
January 21
|
| Category:Far East naval battles of World War I |
rename |
January 27
|
| Category:Far East naval theatre of World War II |
merge |
January 27
|
| Category:Far-left political parties |
no consensus. This is the onlyresult I can come up with for the time being. Renomination is welcome, if also options of upmerging and the problem of daughter categories have been addressed |
January 10
|
| Category:FBI agents convicted of murder |
delete seems to be the consensus of the discussion |
January 1
|
| Category:Fictional dragon-hybrids |
Merge |
January 29
|
| Category:Fictional gymnasts |
keep. The discussion was tending towards delete but a fresh delete nomination should give more clarity on that |
January 20
|
| Category:Fictional outlaws |
no consensus. – |
January 21
|
| Category:Film actresses from Shanghai |
merge as nominated and also Category:Chinese film actresses or Category:Chinese television actresses, as appropriate |
January 31
|
| Category:Films about the United Kingdom |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Films distributed by Paramount/Disney |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Fishguard and Goodwick |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Font Bureau typefaces |
keep. A re-nomination should be allowed if the nominator wishes, since some users focused on the nature of the sparse/unclear rationale |
January 26
|
| Category:Font Bureau typefaces |
 Relisted at 2015 JAN 26 CFD |
January 15
|
| Category:Forests in fiction |
no consensus. Perhaps a renomination would be useful after the articles all get placed in the correct category or categories |
January 31
|
| Category:Former Reformed Protestants |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Free Decentralized Software |
delete |
January 16
|
| Category:French Story |
delete. (For the time being, I've placed The Dukes of the Bourbon castle in Montluçon in Category:History of France.) |
January 19
|
| Category:Frogs of New Zealand |
Merge to Category:Amphibians of New Zealand |
January 23
|
| Category:GA-Class Good articles |
Delete |
January 25
|
| Category:Galician-speaking countries and territories |
Delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Gargoyles in television |
merge Category:Gargoyles in television, Category:Gargoyles in popular culture, Category:Gargoyles in film, and Category:Fictional gargoyles into a new Category:Gargoyles |
January 19
|
| Category:Georgia (country) animated television series by decade |
Delete, already in parent category |
January 22
|
| Category:Golf clubs and courses in Karachi |
delete; merge contents to Category:Golf clubs and courses in Pakistan and Category:Sports venues in Karachi |
January 6
|
| Category:Golf clubs and courses in Klang Valley |
delete; merge contents to Category:Golf clubs and courses in Malaysia and Category:Sports venues in Selangor |
January 6
|
| Category:Groove Awards winners |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Hassan (surname) |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Hereditary peers removed from the House of Lords under the Act 1999 |
Listify |
January 20
|
| Category:Hetrosexual Wikipedians |
delete. Per the discussion below and the discussion for the previous version of this category Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2014 November 29#Category:Straight Wikipedians, I am closing this as a "snow delete", i.e. on the merits. I could also have speedily deleted it as G5 but that might have given rise to a discussion in the future about whether recreations under this or similar names would be eligible for speedy deletion under G4 |
January 18
|
| Category:Highlife albums by Nigerian artists |
Relisted at 2015 FEB 4 CFD |
January 15
|
| Category:Historical Roman Catholic Dioceses in Asia |
result |
January 26
|
| Category:Historically segregated white schools in the United States |
no consensus. Whereas there are good arguments for deletion, the counter keep argument by |
January 17
|
| Category:History of Arizona stubs |
Already deleted |
January 13
|
| Category:Houari Boumédiène |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Images of 1978 |
merge |
January 7
|
| Category:Independent sects in the Latter Day Saint movement |
delete |
January 21
|
| India articles assessed in ((month)) |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:International Car of the Year Winners |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:International Independent Research Consortium |
Delete |
January 16
|
| Category:International sports competitions hosted by the Greenland |
speedily delete as error in name. (The relevant category is at Category:International sports competitions hosted by Greenland.) |
January 23
|
| Category:Iranian Capitals of Culture |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Irish-speaking countries and territories |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Islamic extremist groups restricting education |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Islamist terrorist incidents - 20th century |
rename |
January 27
|
| Islip (town), New York |
no consensus, valid arguments from both sides |
January 6
|
| Category:Israeli military personnel who committed suicide |
no consensus, though there does seem to be consensus that if there is a renomination, the entire tree of Category:Military personnel who committed suicide should be nominated |
January 5
|
| Category:Jewish group structuring |
merge |
January 18
|
| Category:John Maddox Prize winners |
Delete. Lists exists in the article |
January 29
|
| Category:Journal series |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:K.d. lang |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Kahlgrund |
delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Kapiti Coast District |
withdrawn |
January 14
|
| Category:Kapiti Coast |
Merge/rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Language creators |
Relisted at 2015 FEB 3 CFD |
January 9
|
| Category:Latina 30 Under 30 honorees |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Law journals edited by students |
withdrawn |
January 31
|
| Category:LGBT singer-songwriters |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Libyans rabbis |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Liftbacks |
merge |
January 14
|
| Category:Long pop songs |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Maccabiah Games bronze medalists |
No consensus to delete, default to keep. |
January 30
|
| Maccabiah Games categories |
Merge |
January 30
|
| Male and female murderers |
upmerge four: |
January 22
|
| Category:Male professional wrestlers from Jalisco |
Merge |
January 8
|
| Category:Mauritius Wikipedia administration |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Media not suitable for Commons |
rename |
January 28
|
| Category:Medieval Greek astrologers |
delete. (We're only talking about Theophilus of Edessa as far as contents go, so to resolve issues of upmerging or not and to where, users can deal with this with the categorization of the article.) |
January 25
|
| Category:Medieval mythology |
delete |
January 11
|
| Category:Members of the CPPCC National Committee |
rename the first, double upmerge the second to the first and to category:Hong Kong politicians. – |
January 5
|
| Category:Membership top icons |
rename as nominated. This close is no bar to early re-nomination of this and siblings to have "user" prepended, as well as "templates" appended to the others. – |
January 8
|
| Category:Memorial roads of Canada |
delete |
January 3
|
| Mexican TV stations by channel number |
Listify |
January 7
|
| Category:Military installations in Bedfordshire |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Moths of France |
delete. I'm not sure if all those who commented correctly read the nomination and/or examined the contents of the categories, but a straight merge to the corresponding "FOOs of Europe" categories would not be appropriate given that these all contain articles and subcategories about the things in French colonies around the world. |
January 27
|
| Category:Mozart: spurious and doubtful works |
No consensus. Sorry, no real resolution here but there's many issues regarding the existing, scope and titling of these categories and the inclusion criterion, too much for a single CFD discussion it seems. The titling/existence of these categories could be done with a RFC but there should be separate discussions (on the article talk pages) as to whether various articles belong in those categories. The title and scope are two different issues |
January 17
|
| Category:Multidisciplinary WikiProjects |
merge |
January 10
|
| Music in Mississippi |
Delete all, put the only article in these categories into Category:Music of Mississippi |
January 21
|
| Category:Musicians from Fræna |
merge as proposed and to Category:Musicians from Møre og Romsdal |
January 3
|
| Category:National football team kit manufacturers |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:National Heritage Houses of the Philippines |
merge |
January 2
|
| Category:Neo (constructed language) |
delete both |
January 9
|
| Category:Nova Scotia Military Regiments |
merge Category:Nova Scotia Military Regiments to Category:Military regiments raised in Nova Scotia |
January 5
|
| Category:Novial |
no consensus |
January 4
|
| Category:Online-only journals |
keep |
January 28
|
| Category:Open content publishing companies |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Operas by world premiere location subcategories |
Rename. There are two issues here, one was the reanme and the other a listify. If we treat the listify comments as neutral, there is consensus for a reanme. Once the rename is completed, it would be fair for a new discussion on the listify option |
January 21
|
| Category:Opponents of Islamist terrorism |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Oral citations experiment |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Orchids of Austria |
Merge per precedent and as porposed. The main objections here appear to be based on how experts in the field classify these. However the Wikipedia category system is used for its own organization purposes and as part of that we try to avoid over categorization of articles |
January 26
|
| Category:Outdated articles/sources |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Paleontology of Ethiopia |
Delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Panamanian people of Mandinka descent |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Past Grand Muftis |
merge |
January 28
|
| Category:PD-GermanGov |
rename |
January 8
|
| Pentecostal minister categories |
no action |
January 4
|
| People excommunicated by the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints |
no consensus. The factual development - creation of a parent category and moving some people there - seems to be the closest to consensus |
January 22
|
| Category:People from Adamsville, Alabama |
merge |
January 15
|
| Category:People from Cordova, South Carolina |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:People from Heflin, Alabama |
merge |
January 15
|
| Category:People from Oakham, Massachusetts |
merge |
January 11
|
| Category:People from Stella, Missouri |
merge |
January 12
|
| Category:People from the Elloughton-cum-Brough |
merge |
January 17
|
| Category:People from Towamencin Township, Pennsylvania |
merge |
January 8
|
| Category:People from Venice (city) |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:People from Western Australia uncategorised by location |
merge |
January 18
|
| Category:People of Afro-Panamanian descent |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:People who are namesakes of streets in Halifax, Nova Scotia |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:People who recorded Elvis tribute songs |
delete |
January 25
|
| Category:Persian-genre film stubs |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Pet Turtles |
administrative close: category already being discussed, as noted |
January 31
|
| Category:Pet Turtles |
delete per snow and G4 |
January 26
|
| Category:Philosophy reference resources |
rename |
January 11
|
| Category:Physical infrastructure |
merge |
January 2
|
| Category:Pichilemu City Council members, 1894–1897 |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Pikes |
delete (merged contents to Category:Former toll roads in the United States) |
January 15
|
| Pitch and putt competitions in Spain |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Politicians convicted of corruption |
keep. (NAC) |
January 23
|
| Category:Populated places on Iceland's Route 1 |
delete |
January 11
|
| Category:Postal infrastructure in London |
Rename Category:Postal infrastructure in London to Category:Postal infrastructure in the United Kingdom. Create Category:Postal infrastructure as parent, and as as a subcat of Category:Postal system. - |
January 2
|
| Category:Presidents of Biafra |
keep |
January 18
|
| Category:Priests convicted of child sexual abuse |
rename |
January 11
|
| Category:Princess Leonida Bagration of Mukhrani |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Professional wrestlers from Calgary |
Rename to Category:Stampede Wrestling alumni and cleanup. @Bearcat:, @Sillyfolkboy:, can you do the cleanup? |
January 23
|
| Category:Professional wrestlers from Monterrey |
merge. – |
January 8
|
| Category:Q150 |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Quantified human groups |
Delete per WP:OC#SHAREDNAME. - |
January 18
|
| Category:Queensland places with golf clubs and courses |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Queensland places with war memorials |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Radio dramas |
rename. The category restructures can be done outside of CfD. |
January 4
|
| Radio stations by frequency |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:Rawlinsonian Professors of Anglo-Saxon |
No consensus. Made the first a child category of the second |
January 26
|
| Category:Religious antisemitism |
Upmerge to Category:Antisemitism |
January 22
|
| Category:Repulsion (band) songs |
delete |
January 7
|
| Riksdag |
rename. (To address Marcocapelle's question, I suggest that every instance would be a matter dealt with on the talk page for the article about the parliament. The category names then reflect whatever name is selected for the article. In such article name discussions, the standard principles of Wikipedia:Article titles will apply, including WP:UCRN, WP:UE, etc.) |
January 14
|
| Category:Rivers of Kosala |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Rolo Tomassi songs |
delete |
January 7
|
| Russian Street Categories with 1 Article |
double merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Ryukyuan Confucianists |
No consensus to merge. - |
January 17
|
| Category:Saraiki cuisine |
Delete. Note I did edit this category doing cleanup for various nominations. I do not believe that this disqualifies me from closing this |
January 23
|
| Category:Sarwari Qadiri order |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Scientific societies by country |
Merge |
January 23
|
| Category:Scientific societies of Poland |
Merge |
January 23
|
| Category:Scots-speaking countries and territories |
Delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Second City alumni |
Delete. For Category:Second City alumni the decision was to listify, but two lists already exist. S0 even this one can be deleted without loss of information. I'll leave it to the users on how best to combine or redo the existing lists. @Bearcat: maybe you would like to get involved? |
January 18
|
| Category:Singles certified sextuple platinum by the Productores de Música de España |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Smithsonian Institution Archives related |
Delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Social justice activists of Nova Scotia |
delete; merge contents to Category:Canadian activists |
January 3
|
| Category:Songs written by Dean Roland |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Songs written by DJ Kane |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Songs written by José González (singer) |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Spits of Conwy County Borough |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Sportsmen from Brisbane |
merge as proposed. This result doesn't preclude further work/changes being done to the category tree. |
January 30
|
| Category:Sri Lankan people of World War I |
merge; leave redirect |
January 4
|
| Category:Steve Bloomer |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Storylines in fiction |
Keep |
January 22
|
| Category:Streets in Perth |
Renanme Category:Streets in Perth to Category:Streets in Perth, Western Australia. A merge or reverse merge between the roads and streets categories did not gain a consensus due to the multiple options that wound up being proposed here. If that is still needed, feel free to nominate. There appeared to be a consensus to upmerge Category:Streets in Perth central business district, Western Australia to Category:Streets in Perth, Western Australia, but again with the multiple proposals I'm not convinced that the consensus was strong enough to do that merge, so again that should be a new discussion |
January 16
|
| Category:Successful Romanian singles |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Suspected Islamist insurgents |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Tad (band) songs |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Teahouse hosts |
merge |
January 8
|
| Category:Template-impact Wikipedia essays |
delete |
January 9
|
| Terrorism by city |
Rename |
January 22
|
| Category:The Black Dahlia Murder (band) songs |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:The Dillinger Escape Plan songs |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:The Kids in the Hall members |
no consensus to delete, with the balance leaning towards "keep" |
January 16
|
| Category:The Progressives politicians |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary alumni |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Traditional Strega Nonna |
Delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Transport in Telengana |
delete |
January 28
|
| Tribune Media |
rename; if the article name is renamed again, the categories can follow speedily |
January 5
|
| Category:Trotskyist organisations in Northern Ireland |
do not merge |
January 3
|
| Unused WikiProject India sub-categories |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:User:333-blue |
Delete |
January 20
|
| Category:User:Muffingg |
Delete |
January 16
|
| Category:UsesSecondParam |
Delete (by creator of category). Satisfied speedy deletion criterion G2 (test page). |
January 17
|
| Category:Valid SVG |
Rename to Category:Wikipedia images in SVG format |
January 7
|
| Category:Video of the Year on VH1 Soul VIBE Awards |
Delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Vietnam War military equipment of Australia |
merge |
January 7
|
| Category:Volvo Master venues |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Warhol superstars |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Washington (state) sportspeople stubs |
Relisted at 2015 FEB 4 CFD |
January 12
|
| Category:Websites blocked in the United Kingdom |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Welsh-speaking countries and territories |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Wikipedia media files with subtitles |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Wikipedia media files |
merge |
January 7
|
| Category:Wikipedian qin xiao players |
Merge |
January 20
|
| Category:Wikipedians who like Adele |
delete, with support for a broader discussion on the underlying principles of these categories |
January 31
|
| Category:WikiProject Beauty Pageants |
keep. As I said closing the MfD with the same result, I'd need to see much stronger arguments before deleting a WikiProject anyone is active in |
January 20
|
| Category:WikiProject NIOSH templates |
no consensus. A re-nomination would be fine if no further contents are forthcoming. |
January 6
|
| Category:WikiProjects Based on the Turnkey Project |
Delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Windsor Suburban Roads |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Winners of Automobile Magazine Automobile of the Year |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Winners of What Car? Car of the Year |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Winners of Wheels Car of the Year |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Winners of World Car of the Year |
Delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Women's studies journal stubs |
Upmerge |
January 29
|
| Category:World Digital Library related |
no consensus. There are some reasonable suggestions in the discussion, may be they should be explored |
January 27
|
| World Rugby |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:World War I mines |
renamed Category:Tunnel warfare in World War I: strong support for doing something, but not doing the original nom; this alt had multiple and reasonably-reasoned support |
January 31
|
| Category:World War II images |
no consensus |
January 8
|
| Category:Young Australian of the Year Award winners |
delete |
January 30
|
