| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:1938 British television series debuts |
rename (non-admin closure) |
September 11
|
| Category:1939 British television series debuts |
rename as nominated (non-admin closure) |
September 11
|
| Category:2017 television series debuts |
keep. (non-admin closure) |
September 9
|
| Category:Academy Award nominated films |
speedy delete WP:G4. – |
September 16
|
| Category:American military personnel by state |
rename to option B |
September 14
|
| Category:American radio DJs |
no consensus. As noted, it looks like an WP:ENGVAR issue. I have created a redirect. |
September 5
|
| Category:American women of Indian descent in politics |
delete |
September 17
|
| Category:Amphetamine alkaloids |
no consensus |
September 3
|
| Category:Armories on the National Register of Historic Places in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
delete; merge contents to Category:Armories on the National Register of Historic Places in Pennsylvania |
September 20
|
| Category:Article Incubator articles by quality |
delete |
September 7
|
| Category:B Flow |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 13
|
| Category:Basketball clubs in Iceland |
Speedy delete under CSD G7 |
September 5
|
| Category:Basketball clubs in Sweden |
Speedy delete under CSD G7 |
September 5
|
| Category:Basketball clubs in Tunisia and elsewhere |
merge/rename |
September 5
|
| Category:Baton Rouge mayoral elections |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Beaches in Turkey |
merge, noting that there is a specific guideline on this |
September 6
|
| Category:Beaches in |
rename |
September 6
|
| Beverage |
Rename all |
September 1
|
| Category:Bhatti |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 18
|
| Category:Bien de Interés Cultural landmarks in the Province of Malaga |
speedy deleted. @Rathfelder:, in the future, please tag this for WP:G7 instead. This should not be nominated for CFD |
September 7
|
| Category:Biopsychology |
Merge |
September 10
|
| Category:Biota of Turkestan |
rename to Category:Biota of Central Asia and merge to Category:Flora of Central Asia (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Birds of Switzerland |
merge |
September 19
|
| Category:Births in Ternopil |
merge. People who were born there but can't comfortably said to be "from" there can be removed from the category. As noted, this is a great example where ambiguity in meaning actually benefits a category scheme |
September 8
|
| Category:Blade (comics) television series |
delete; upmerge contents |
September 14
|
| Category:Boats designed by E.N. Maryanov |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Books by Richard Shea |
delete. I've deleted the book article, so now I'll do the same for this empty category |
September 10
|
| Category:British television series based on non-British television series |
procedural keep. Marcocapelle's argument is compelling. This nomination fails to include any of the highly-similar sibling categories or even Category:British television series based on American television series, which is a sub-category of the one nominated here. As I see it, my only options are to relist and at least consider the sub-category in conjunction with this one or to procedurally keep the category and allow another editor to open the comprehensive discussion I think everyone would like to be having. The latter seems substantially more attractive given the positions expressed in this discussion. ~ |
September 9
|
| Category:Buildings in Toodyay |
Rename |
September 18
|
| Category:Burial at Zuhuratbaba Cemetery |
delete per creator request |
September 19
|
| Category:Buses in Doncaster |
Rename |
September 18
|
| Category:Caribbean model stubs |
merge. – |
September 11
|
| Category:Carniolan theologians |
withdrawn |
September 3
|
| Category:Censuses in Australia |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
September 3
|
| Category:CH network shows |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 1
|
| Category:Checkuser requests to be listed |
Delete |
September 6
|
| Category:City University London |
Rename |
September 2
|
| Category:Connected contributors |
renamed by author |
September 1
|
| Category:Crime in Columbia |
speedy delete. – |
September 12
|
| Category:De La Salle Brothers schools in Hong Kong |
rename per this discussion |
September 28
|
| Deaths in 1927 by month |
Delete |
September 9
|
| Category:Dramatic and literary genres |
merge to Category:Theatrical music genres (non-admin closure) |
September 21
|
| English, Scottish and Welsh radio |
rename (non-admin closure) |
September 13
|
| Category:Exophonic writers |
delete |
September 12
|
| Category:Expatriate basketball people in Montenegro |
 Relisted at 2016 SEP 29 CFD |
September 13
|
| Category:Faith-based literature |
delete |
September 6
|
| Category:Feminism and transgender topics |
rename |
September 15
|
| Category:Festivals on the Navajo Nation |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 13
|
| Category:Fictional jewels |
rename |
September 3
|
| Category:Fictional Los Angeles Police Department police officers |
rename (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Film speculative fiction |
selective merge to Category:Speculative fiction films. It has already been moved by |
September 6
|
| Category:Films about hebephilia |
no consensus. (Category was not tagged with Template:Cfd; nominators, please remember to do so, otherwise no changes can be made as a result of the discussion when a consensus is reached.) |
September 6
|
| Category:Films about marriage, unions and partnerships in the Philippines |
merge |
September 18
|
| Category:Films based on teleplays |
rename |
September 13
|
| Category:Films directed by Krishnan-Panju |
renamed. (non-admin closure) |
September 16
|
| Category:Films set in New York (state) |
merge to Category:Films set in New York. I left a redirect (non-admin closure) |
September 23
|
| Category:Flora of northern South America |
Keep |
September 1
|
| Category:Football kits with incorrect pattern |
Rename |
September 8
|
| Category:Fruits by colour |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Genetic disease |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
September 1
|
| Category:Genetic disorders |
rename. ~ |
September 12
|
| Category:Ghanaian football personalities |
delete category and recategorize articles when needed. (non-admin closure) |
September 2
|
| Category:GJ 1214 |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Globalization-related theories |
delete |
September 20
|
| Category:Hebephilia |
Relisted at 2016 SEP 29 CFD. Category was not tagged with Template:Cfd, so I have tagged it and relisted it. |
September 6
|
| Category:High schools in Nepal |
merge |
September 21
|
| Category:Hindi-Tamil Dubbed version series |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 11
|
| Category:Hospitals in Miri |
delete empty category (non-admin closure) |
September 18
|
| Category:Hospitals in Sibu |
merge, also to Category:Sibu (non-admin closure) |
September 18
|
| Category:Independent artists |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
September 1
|
| Category:Information, knowledge, and uncertainty |
no consensus. Obviously this result is without prejudice to a future proposal to rename or otherwise change the category |
September 19
|
| Category:Institute of the Brothers of the Christian Schools (Hong Kong) |
rename option A. (non-admin closure) |
September 5
|
| Category:ISRO space probes |
reverse merge, as this seems desirable in order to match the hierarchy Category:ISRO vehicles. – |
September 7
|
| Category:Judges of Supreme Court of Sierra Leone |
rename. Should someone find some information in the future which would support using "Judges" in preference to "Justices", we can have a new nomination to change that word back. (From an English common law perspective, which is the system SL has adopted (or had imposed on it, depending on the POV), I think the terms are more or less interchangeable. In some jurisdictions, judges of superior courts are called "justices", while judges of inferior courts are called "judges". The SC of SL is a superior court, so "Justice" seems relatively safe to me.) |
September 6
|
| Category:Judicial system of Bhutan |
|
September 9
|
| Category:Khouw family of Tamboen |
merge. Can be reconsidered if an article is written |
September 17
|
| Category:La Salle College |
merge; rename target to Category:Lasallian schools in Hong Kong. See also here |
September 13
|
| Category:LGBT American people of Cambodian descent |
merge as nominated and to appropriate "American people of FOOian descent" categories |
September 19
|
| Category:Liability |
split |
September 2
|
| Category:Lilium in culture |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
September 1
|
| Category:List notification templates |
Merge |
September 6
|
| Category:Livins people bhind |
speedy deleted, gibberish |
September 6
|
| Category:Local landmarks in Boston, Massachusetts |
delete; merge contents to Category:Landmarks in Boston, Massachusetts |
September 8
|
| Luxembourg (city) |
Rename, revisit if the main article is renamed |
September 17
|
| Category:Made in Chelsea cast members |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
September 9
|
| Category:Manga based on light novels |
delete both; merge contents of Category:Manga based on light novels to Category:Anime and manga based on light novels and those of Category:Manga based on novels to Category:Anime and manga based on novels |
September 18
|
| Category:Mauritian long male jumpers |
speedy rename. (non-admin closure) |
September 10
|
| Category:Mayors of Sulphur, Louisiana |
dual upmerge (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Methamphetamines |
no consensus |
September 3
|
| Category:Military of Palestine |
rename. Some clean-up/further action/possible re-nominations are going to be required after this is done. I'm not going to do this clean-up as part of the close of this discussion, so if interested users could do so, that would be helpful. |
September 15
|
| Category:North American Methodism |
rename |
September 19
|
| Category:Northern South America |
Delete |
September 1
|
| Category:Objects by type |
delete |
September 18
|
| Category:Ohloh templates |
upmerged. (non-admin closure) |
September 14
|
| Category:Order of Sultan Qaboos |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 17
|
| Category:Order of the Liberator |
delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Order of the Smile |
delete |
September 20
|
| Category:Pakistani terrorists |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 23
|
| Category:Parliamentary aspirants (Ghana) |
delete. ~ |
September 11
|
| Peerage titles with only one holder |
merge as nominated (non-admin closure) |
September 11
|
| Category:Pennsylvania talk radio hosts |
merge (non-admin closure) |
September 11
|
| Category:People from Cold Spring, Minnesota |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
September 5
|
| Category:People from Holdingford, Minnesota |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
September 4
|
| Category:People from Mooringsport, Louisiana |
merge (non-admin closure) |
September 12
|
| Category:People from North Liberty, Iowa |
merge (non-admin closure) |
September 13
|
| Category:People from Voluntown, Connecticut |
merge (non-admin closure) |
September 16
|
| Category:People of pre-statehood U.S. states |
no consensus to rename |
September 8
|
| Category:Pilot-Cosmonauts of the USSR |
merge |
September 4
|
| Category:Power transmission operators |
no consensus |
September 3
|
| Category:Radiological weapon |
rename. (non-admin closure) |
September 6
|
| Category:Rally racing terminology |
Merge |
September 5
|
| Category:Recipients of Australian campaign medals |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the Canadian Forces Decoration |
delete |
September 13
|
| Category:Recipients of the Canadian Volunteer Service Medal |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the Collar of the Order of the National Coat of Arms |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
September 5
|
| Category:Recipients of the Colonial Medal |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the Federation Star |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the Fiji Independence Medal |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 17
|
| Category:Recipients of the Insignia for the Military Wounded |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the International Force East Timor Medal |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the National Medal (Australia) |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Recipients of the Purple Heart medal |
delete |
September 17
|
| Category:Recipients of the Reserve Force Decoration |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic Church in Cambridge |
no consensus |
September 3
|
| Category:Roman colonies |
rename to Category:Coloniae (Roman). The nomination changed mid-way through the discussion, so it is a little bit difficult to track. It would be helpful if users would strike the old nomination and add the new one so that we can easily see datestamps for the changes, etc. But after muddling through the sequence of events, there does seem to be a rough consensus here to rename |
September 7
|
| Category:Royal National Theatre Company members |
delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Saut-al-falah-trust |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
September 2
|
| Category:Screenplays by Harlan Ellison |
rename to Category:Television episodes written by Harlan Ellison |
September 13
|
| Category:Society by nationality |
rename/merge. This discussion did not decide to change the format of the subcategories; they were not nominated. |
September 2
|
| Category:Sojourned |
nomination closed as user error |
September 28
|
| Category:Somalian linguists |
not merged. (non-admin closure) |
September 20
|
| Category:Somalian people by occupation |
keep (non-admin closure) |
September 20
|
| Category:Songs about time |
Delete both |
September 1
|
| Category:Star Trek crossovers |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
September 3
|
| Category:Steamboat articles by route |
Rename to Category:Steamboats by body of water |
September 3
|
| Category:Steamboat terminology |
merge |
September 3
|
| Category:Surrealist video games |
Delete |
September 10
|
| Category:Teleplays by Joss Whedon |
rename |
September 13
|
| Category:Teleplays |
merge |
September 13
|
| Terms to terminology |
Rename |
September 2
|
| Category:Thoughtcrime |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 16
|
| Category:Tomorrow's World presenters |
Delete |
September 6
|
| Category:Top Gear people |
no consensus |
September 6
|
| Category:Traditional Vietnamese objects |
delete |
September 18
|
| Category:West Coast of the United States-related lists |
delete and prune as originally nominated, except prune Category:Regions of the West Coast of the United States as described rather than deleting it |
September 9
|
| Category:WFMU DJs |
merge |
September 20
|
| Category:Wikipedia articles in need of updating from Spetember 2016 |
speedied |
September 1
|
| Category:Wikipedia pages containing incorrect parameters |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Wikipedians interested in Northern South America |
Delete |
September 1
|
| Category:WWE Fatal 4-Way |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
September 5
|
| Category:Zattoo |
delete (non-admin closure) |
September 13
|
