Jump to content

Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Archive debates/2021 June index

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The following is an alphabetical index of decisions made at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion.

Category Decision Discussion_log
1431 establishments in Ukraine delete as currently empty. – June 18
1432 establishments in England no consensus. WP:SMALLCAT does not apply as this is part of a well-established structure from year 1000 onwards. – June 18
1596 establishments in Italy no consensus, with the outcome Keep. For the record, this now contains 3 sub-cats and 5 other articles June 18
1596 establishments in Ukraine keep. However, the category is currently empty. During the discussion it was stated that the category only contained a redirect for a village. The village name was not recorded below. It may be that the 1596 date was based on "first-mentioned" rather than an actual establishment date, which would be deprecated by the discussion to date at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2021_July_27#Establishments_based_on_first-mentioned_dates. Therefore I am assuming that the village redirect was removed from the category in good faith. The outcome is therefore delete for now as empty but with permission to re-create the category if an article is written on a 1596 establishment within the present-day borders of Ukraine. – June 18
1676 establishments in Ukraine keep. – June 18
Category:16th-century Arab people rename. Since the target already exists, this will be implemented as a merge. (non-admin closure) June 29
Category:17th-century English merchants no consensus. June 6
1805 establishments in Lithuania keep. – June 18
1846 in Nebraska speedy delete. June 17
Category:1894 establishments in Nigeria delete for now, but I will implement this by redirecting this one to the Lagos Colony sub-cat, as this is part of a hierarchy, see Category:19th-century establishments in Nigeria, so a wider discussion on Category:Establishments in Nigeria by century would be would be appropriate. – June 23
1910s in the Republic of Macedonia merge/delete per amended nomination. New categories e.g. Category:1910s in North Macedonia will be deleted as WP:G7. – June 10
Category:1980s Indian superhero films no consensus. – June 25
Category:2018 European Athletics U18 Championships delete June 8
Category:21st-century Korean people keep for now, considering that the subcategories by occupation have not been nominated (non-admin closure) June 10
Category:70-minute and longer albums delete; I have started a bare list at List of albums longer than 70 minutes. – June 21
Category:ABC journalists associated with the Liberal Party of Australia delete June 5
Aboriginal gods and goddesses rename. June 2
Category:Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences members delete June 6
Category:Ala Vaikunthapurramuloo rename (non-admin closure) June 4
Category:Album awards keep (non-admin closure) June 3
Category:All articles missing payload orbit parameters delete June 21
Category:Alumni of Queen's Park Secondary School rename June 20
Category:American Council on Science and Health delete June 11
Category:American professional wrestlers of Panamanian descent delete June 19
Category:American Wikipedians of Jewish descent delete June 9
Category:Amsterdam artists merge June 2
Category:Amy Adams delete (non-admin closure) June 4
Category:Ancient Roman proconsuls no consensus (non-admin closure) June 13
Anglican bishops in Africa and Oceania rename June 20
Anglican bishops in Africa rename June 8
Category:Animated western (genre) animation delete June 9
Category:Animators from San Antonio merge June 16
Category:Anna Lesko delete (non-admin closure) June 28
Category:Anti-Taliban users delete (non-admin closure) June 23
Category:Architects of YMCA buildings delete June 10
Category:Articles created by Dhaneesh delete (non-admin closure) June 24
Category:Aspirational Districts in India deleted June 28
Category:Associates of the Royal College of Organists no consensus June 8
Category:Auburn hair merge (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Auckland rugby union players withdrawn nomination (non-admin closure) June 15
Category:Australian football chairmen and investors delete June 22
Category:Australian Labor Party officials do not merge June 21
Category:Baliwal speedy move, evidently created in category space in error. – June 13
Category:BCC crystal habit rename all as nominated, except add "Chemical elements with" at the start of the proposed category names. Create a new Category:Chemical elements by crystal structure as the parent June 7
Category:Bests schools in Horana delete June 16
Category:Bini delete (non-admin closure) June 9
Category:Biographical dictionaries of women writers merge (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Births in Eure-et-Loir merge June 22
Category:Bisexual rappers merge June 3
Category:Bishonen test categories Nomination withdrawn. It was certainly not my intention to touch such a nerve. I would benefit from moving on to other WP work; perhaps others would as well. (non-admin closure) June 22
Category:Bishops of Kotor rename June 22
Category:Black British members of the Parliament of the United Kingdom merge to Category:Black British MPs. There was as slight preference for this category over the nominated one. June 6
Category:Book covers by Michael Koelsch delete (non-admin closure) June 11
Category:Books by Leonard Woolf no consensus June 17
Category:Books with cover art by Michael Koelsch delete. As of this close, Category:Michael Koelsch, Category:Book covers by Michael Koelsch, and Category:Film posters by Michael Koelsch still exist June 3
Category:Boris Stoyanov delete (non-admin closure) June 5
Category:Breendonk concentration camp rename all using "Breendonk prison camp", so the top one becomes Category:Breendonk prison camp, and the speedy-page-nominated Category:Breendonk concentration camp survivors becomes Category:Breendonk prison camp survivors. – June 12
Bridges with bike paths delete. June 18
Category:Britons who assisted Jewish refugees to escape Nazism delete. Consensus determined that this particular category is not defining. Alternate names changed the scope of the category, which would have called for the removal of Hilda Buckmaster and led to it being emptied and deleted regardless June 12
Brooklyn Bulldogs football rename June 3
Category:Buddhists by occupation merge June 4
Category:California Yacht Club sailors delete. – June 22
Categories related to World Para Athletics European Championships rename June 2
Category:Category:Albums produced by Bangladesh (record producer) keep. June 7
Category:Category:Song recordings produced by Bangladesh (record producer) keep. – June 7
Category:Category:Songs written by Bangladesh (record producer) keep. June 7
Category:Chairmen of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation rename (non-admin closure) June 5
Category:Chairmen of the National Council (Namibia) rename (non-admin closure) June 4
Category:Cheap meats delete (non-admin closure) June 19
Category:Children of Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex merge. June 6
Category:Children's Oncology Group members delete June 12
Category:Christianity in Joseon withdrawn (non-admin closure) June 5
Churches by name delete. For the disambiguation pages, there is already Category:Church building disambiguation pages. – June 29
Category:Clean-up categories no consensus June 17
Constituencies of the Parliament of the United Kingdom rename June 20
Category:County attorneys merge and redirect. – June 8
Category:COVID Recovery Group members delete. June 17
Category:COVID-19 pandemic-related lists speedy keep. (non-admin closure) June 7
Category:Critics of Planned Parenthood delete June 23
Category:Cyprus–Northern Cyprus relations merge and redirect June 7
Category:Databases keep June 27
Category:Deaths from stroke delete June 19
Category:DEFCON 2 conflicts delete June 26
Category:DeKalb County-Fulton County, Georgia (U.S. state) in fiction delete (non-admin closure) June 26
Category:Died in Bydgoszcz delete (non-admin closure) June 17
Diplomatic visits by national leaders purge/clean up; no consensus to merge.– June 23
Category:Disney Renaissance singles delete June 10
Category:Dualism merge June 14
Category:Dvaita merge June 5
Category:DYK templates merge June 14
Category:DYK videos delete June 23
Category:DYK merge June 9
Category:DYK/Editnotices/Page merge (non-admin closure) June 15
Category:DYK/Empty categories WP:SOFTDELETE (non-admin closure) June 14
Category:DYK/Nominations merge June 15
Category:DYK/Pages delete. June 24
Category:DYK/Pages/Documentation merge. June 24
Category:DYK/Pages/Redirects merge June 15
Category:DYK/Project pages delete (non-admin closure) June 15
Category:DYK/Successful nominations delete. June 22
Category:EarthBound character redirects to lists merge June 10
Egyptian Premier League seasons merge June 13
Category:Eldest sons of barons rename to Category:Eldest sons of British hereditary barons and purge June 24
Category:Emilie Autumn delete (non-admin closure) June 4
Category:Engineers of Vietnamese descent merge June 14
Category:English words prefixed with eigen- delete June 10
Category:Entertainment Software Association members speedy delete as WP:CSD#G7 June 6
Establishments in the Russian Empire when there was no Lithuania no consensus, with the outcome Keep, which is in line with other Keep decisions in similar nominations below. I will reinstate the formerly-deleted Category:1902_establishments_in_Lithuania and Category:1912_establishments_in_Lithuania in recognition of the larger participation here than in their former CFDs (which are linked in this discussion) and the adjacent Category:1912_establishments_in_Latvia (CFD) June 18
Establishments in Ukraine when most of Ukraine was under the Russian Empire keep. I will therefore reinstate Category:1812 establishments in Ukraine in view of the greater participation here than at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2021_May_10#1912_establishments_in_Ukraine. – June 18
Establishments in United States Civil Administration of the Ryukyu Islands merge/rename to existing Okinawa hierarchy for now. A further nomination may be held to rename all of that hierarchy to Okinawa Prefecture or Ryukyu Islands. – June 8
Category:Falcons (rugby team) players rename June 15
Category:Famous dogs merge (non-admin closure) June 23
Category:Fans rename to Category:Ventilation fans June 9
Female premiers and first ministers merge both into the new Category:Women heads of government of non-sovereign entities June 2
Category:Fictional criminals on soap operas do not delete, so rename to Category:Fictional criminals in soap operas. – June 10
Category:Fictional Taoists delete (non-admin closure) June 2
Category:Film posters by Michael Koelsch delete (non-admin closure) June 11
Category:Films associated with the Beatles rename June 12
Category:Films associated with the Bee Gees merge and purge as nominated (non-admin closure) June 12
Category:Films featuring luck delete. June 8
Category:Films with White Washed Characters delete June 21
Category:Fire departments in Westchester County, New York merge/delete June 16
Category:Flemish Calvinist and Reformed theologians delete; disperse contents June 16
Category:Flemish sculptors rename June 20
Category:Form delete June 5
Category:Fortune 40 Under 40 recipients delete June 26
Category:French Islamologists split June 20
Category:Frequent flyer programs associated with credit cards merge June 1
Category:Frisian botanists upmerge to Category:Frisian scientists June 30
Category:Fulbright Scholars deleted June 28
Category:G-rated films delete June 8
Category:Gangsters who died in prison custody delete June 8
Category:Genocide deniers keep as container category (non-admin closure) June 17
Category:Georgia (country) in the Eurovision Song Contest keep (non-admin closure) June 8
Category:Glee (TV series) songs speedy delete WP:G4. I will move Category:Lists of songs in Glee up into Category:Glee (TV series). – June 22
Category:Golden Orange Award merge to parents. – June 25
Category:Griffons (rugby team) players rename June 15
Category:Hawke's Bay Magpies players rename June 19
Category:Healers rename. June 18
Category:Heterocyclic compounds (1 ring) rename. June 24
Category:Hindu acharyas merge June 8
Category:Hindu theologians merge Category:Hindu theologians and Category:Hindu philosophers into a new Category:Hindu philosophers and theologians. Rename century categories to "philosophers and theologians". June 6
Category:Hospitals that took Katrina evacuees delete (non-admin closure) June 12
Category:Hospitals with adolescent clinics delete June 20
Category:HSA Foundation members deleted June 28
Category:IATA members delete June 23
Category:Independent Colleges of Southern California delete June 23
Indian Jain monarchs merge June 21
Category:Indigenous American Wikipedians no consensus June 10
Category:Indoor ice hockey venues in New Orleans delete (non-admin closure) June 29
Category:Infectious disease-related lists keep. (non-admin closure) June 7
Category:Insiders (Australian TV program) panelists delete June 8
Category:International Stability Operations Association delete June 27
Interviews by interviewee merge all (non-admin closure) June 22
Category:Islamic scholars in Egypt no consensus June 13
Category:Islamic scholars in the United Kingdom no consensus June 12
Category:Jain phrases delete after ensuring all member pages are in other Jain categories. – June 3
Category:Jain scholars merge/rename; remove Kaalingar and Manakkudavar from the Jainism category June 6
Category:Jin dynasty (266–420) people related to the Three Kingdoms split. June 12
Category:Joseon Dynasty people rename June 9
Category:Joy (singer) delete June 12
Category:Keynote Speaker delete (non-admin closure) June 17
Category:Kingdoms of old Sri Lanka delete June 16
Category:Kit-Kat Club delete, adding the main article and sub-cat into appropriate parent categories. – June 25
Category:Knights of Pythias buildings in West Virginia merge as nominated and to Category:Clubhouses in West Virginia June 16
Category:Korean Buddhism writers merge June 9
Category:Kuwaiti people of Indian descent delete, as I find that the arguments for this outcome are persuasive. – June 11
Category:Lambrakis Democratic Youth merge June 23
Category:Latvian political party shortname templates merge June 23
Category:Leadership Institute alumni and associates delete June 9
Category:Legislatures of Canadian provinces and territories reverse merge. The Legislative assemblies category page is far older, so I will move it over the Legislatures category page. – June 22
Category:Leopards (rugby team) players rename June 15
Category:LGBT gangsters delete June 3
LGBT-related films by year merge June 14
LGBT-related films by year, redux keep June 25
Category:Linux distributions procedural close. This is outside the scope of CFD June 26
Category:Lions (Super Rugby) rename June 15
Category:List A cricket leagues merge (non-admin closure) June 17
Category:List of film directional debuts delete June 14
Category:Lists of awards received by Puerto Rican musician no consensus June 28
Category:Lists of violent incidents in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict rename June 7
Category:Locomotives that appeared in Chuggington delete (non-admin closure) June 26
Category:Loredana Zefi delete (non-admin closure) June 10
Los Angeles County, California speedily renamed. @Aidan721: there was no need to also list them on the speedy page, as they could have been speedily processed from here; but no harm done. – June 18
Category:Low linked articles delete (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Madonna (entertainer) no consensus June 22
Category:Male dancers from Catalonia withdrawn (non-admin closure) June 16
Category:Maltese merchants merge June 23
Category:Marine meteorology and sailing rename (non-admin closure) June 29
Category:Mayoral elections in Springfield, Missouri merge (non-admin closure) June 20
Category:Medieval Flemish nobility split. June 24
Category:Medieval Irish merchants delete June 6
Category:Members of the Athenaeum Club, London delete June 11
Category:Members of The Club delete June 24
Category:Members of the Council of Fifty delete June 22
Category:Members of the House of Commons of Canada with military service rename and purge as nominated June 21
Category:Members of the Motion Picture Association delete June 22
Category:Members of the National Puzzlers' League delete June 19
Category:Metafictional characters delete June 17
Category:Metafictional characters procedurally closed (non-admin closure) June 28
Category:Michael Koelsch delete (non-admin closure) June 11
Ministers-President of communities and regions of Belgium rename June 2
Category:Minority Leaders of the United States House of Representatives (etc.) rename June 18
Category:Missing in action rename to Category:Military personnel missing in action. – June 24
Category:Monthly clean-up category (Articles missing payload orbit parameters) counter delete June 21
Category:Monthly clean-up category (Articles that do not specify whether all their radiocarbon dates are calibrated or not) counter keep (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Monthly clean-up category (Articles with uncited categories) counter delete (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Monthly clean-up category (Low linked articles) counter delete June 21
Category:Monthly clean-up category (Pages where template include size is exceeded) counter delete June 21
Category:Monthly clean-up category (TV articles of unclear notability) counter delete (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Monthly clean-up category (Wikipedians having been offered adoption) counter delete June 21
Category:Monuments associated with the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki rename June 5
Mosques by country and Islamic branch merge June 5
Category:Moths of Western Asia merge to Category:Moths of the Middle East June 18
Category:Music audio upmerge - note that the category only contains subCategory:MIDI files at this moment (non-admin closure) June 24
Nantucket merge/rename June 2
Category:Natural cultivars delete June 3
Category:Natural disasters in the Empire of Japan merge as nominated. For the record, Category:History of the Empire of Japan, Category:History of the Empire of Japan by topic and Category:Disasters in the Empire of Japan all become empty. – June 13
Category:Near-Mars objects merge (non-admin closure) June 19
Category:New Zealand bishops keep June 1
Category:New Zealand seafloor (oceanography) rename to Category:Geography of the New Zealand seabed. – June 18
Category:Niskanen Center delete June 30
Category:Non-nationals associated with the Pitcairn Islands delete (the subcat is already in Category:Pitcairn Islands politicians) (non-admin closure) June 2
Category:OCLC members delete (non-admin closure) June 17
Category:Order of Railway Conductors merge (non-admin closure) June 10
Category:Organisations associated with the Bengal Renaissance delete (and reparent Category:Vangiya Sahitya Parishad‎ as proposed) June 2
Paintings in a collection rename June 25
Category:Participants in the Les Houches Physics Summer School 1990 delete. – June 29
Category:People associated with the Boy Scouts of America delete; subcategories moved to Category:Boy Scouts of America June 3
Category:People Born in Union City, New Jersey merge June 30
People by nationality and Chinese language descent merge June 4
Category:People expelled from Freemasonry delete June 9
Category:People in Hindu mythology rename June 18
Category:People of Sichuanese descent delete June 20
Category:People who memorized the Bible delete (non-admin closure) June 29
Category:People with dependent personality disorder delete June 20
Category:People with Guillain–Barré syndrome delete June 7
Category:People with Lyme disease delete Category:People with Lyme disease. Category:Deaths from Lyme disease was deleted as an empty category while this discussion was ongoing June 7
Category:Peptidase rename. – June 6
Category:Persian astrologers merge June 23
Category:Persons charged under the Hong Kong national security law rename to Category:People convicted under the Hong Kong national security law and purge June 24
Category:Philadelphia Society members delete June 19
Category:Play characters by year of introduction no consensus. Nominator blocked as sockpuppet so I'm closing this discussion which hasn't elicited any response. June 30
Category:Play characters no consensus. Nominator blocked as sockpuppet so I'm closing this discussion which hasn't elicited any response. June 30
Category:Political and economic think tanks based in Karachi soft delete/merge as nominated (non-admin closure) June 30
Political party leadership elections rename June 24
Category:Political prisoners convert to container category by organisation designating people as political prisoners/prisoners of conscience. Although a majority of participants would prefer to keep the category and discuss inclusion on a case-by-case basis, on this occasion the arguments based on Wikipedia policies outweigh the numbers June 29
Category:Populated coastal places in Massachusetts merge all to Category:Populated coastal places in Massachusetts June 21
Category:Presidential speechwriters rename to Category:Speechwriters for presidents of the United States. – June 11
Category:Private Secretaries to the Duke of York rename (non-admin closure) June 22
Category:Pro14 rename June 15
Category:Protestant megachurches merge. Category:Protestant megachurches in the United States could also be nominated for renaming June 9
Category:Pumas (rugby team) players delete June 15
Quran translators merge all except Category:Translators of the Quran into Bengali June 16
Category:Racemate rename June 6
Category:Record labels owned by women delete June 3
Category:Reich Main Security Office personnel rename June 22
Category:Reich Main Security Office rename June 22
Category:Roman gentes withdrawn, somewhat agree with the counter-rationale provided — Preceding unsigned comment added by June 5
Category:Romanian professional boxers delete June 30
Category:Roosevelt Institute delete June 27
Category:Royal Institution Christmas Lectures delete. June 24
Category:Rusyn Wikipedians delete June 10
Category:Salimata et Taséré FC players merge, which will be implemented by renaming and redirecting the old page. – June 29
Sectarian violence by country merge and move articles as nominated June 11
Category:SEMA members delete June 18
Category:Sexual misconduct allegations involving Buddhist leaders delete June 3
Shia–Sunni secterian violence by country merge as WP:SOFTDELETE. – June 24
Category:Silent feature films from Georgia (country) withdrawn (non-admin closure) June 5
Category:Sinhalese disambiguate. While most votes were for deletion, there was no explicit opposition against disambiguation. (non-admin closure) June 29
Category:Songs about chess delete June 10
Category:Songs about disco no consensus. If someone wants to nominate this again, please first check that the category members are within appropriate sub-cats of Category:Disco songs; that does not yet appear to be the case, but it could be a useful justification for further discussion. – June 18
Category:Songs about nightingales delete June 3
Category:Songs about Tulsa no consensus June 20
Category:Songs in 7/4 delete (non-admin closure) June 20
Category:Songs written by Edna Osser WP:SOFTDELETE (non-admin closure) June 7
Category:Sool, Somalia rename June 12
Southeastern Massachusetts categories merge June 21
Category:Spacecraft by launch system keep June 8
Category:Spacecraft by launch system/* procedural close, the discussion has meanwhile been relisted (non-admin closure) June 4
Category:Spouses of Presidents of the Philippines (etc.) rename June 18
Category:Stanisław Wyspiański rename June 14
Category:Star vs. the Forces of Evil no consensus (non-admin closure) June 21
Category:Stellar physics delete. Nothing to merge June 27
Category:Strict nature reserves of Portugal merge (non-admin closure) June 2
Subcategories of Category:Paintings by collection rename June 23
Category:Superhero television series withdrawn (non-admin closure) June 3
Category:Sylheti writing system merge (non-admin closure) June 17
Category:Taos Institute delete June 24
Category:Tatar Wikipedians delete June 9
Category:Techstars alumni deleted June 28
Category:Teen superhero television shows rename June 3
Category:Templates associated with Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge rename (non-admin closure) June 1
Category:Ten-cent coins no consensus June 7
Category:The Peter G. Peterson Foundation delete. June 25
Category:The Translators Memorial Monument delete (non-admin closure) June 23
Category:Theatres des Vampires members delete (non-admin closure) June 10
Category:Thiometallates keep. June 18
Category:Towns in Kalutara delete June 16
Category:Towns near Bellapitiya delete June 16
Category:Turkish Kurdish people do not merge. There may be support for a purge and reverse merge, if nominated. Note that the category was not tagged with Template:Cfm June 8
Category:United States flag flying days keep. – June 7
Category:United States regional and state political parties rename June 22
Category:University towns delete June 7
Category:User en-ca merge June 4
Category:User pt-br rename June 4
Category:Venezuelan nationalists delete (non-admin closure) June 29
Category:VIAF not on Wikidata delete. – June 4
Category:Video game secret characters delete June 27
Category:Video games with diacritics in their titles delete. 03:08, 24 June 2021 (UTC) June 16
Category:Vinod Kumar speedily moved to Draft:Vinod Kumar (Punjabi actor). – June 13
Category:Voice of India no consensus to delete, but rename to Category:Voice of India writers. This is without prejudice to a new nomination for deletion since there was no consensus on that point June 5
Category:Water polo players by position (and gender) (and nationality) (and handedness) administrative close: categories were already deleted as empty. The categories' creator agreed to an alternate categorization scheme June 12
Category:Wendy (singer) delete. Note that Category:Wendy (singer) songs is not being deleted; I have ensured that it is linked to and from the other current contents of the nominated category. – June 24
Category:Western Province (rugby team) players rename June 15
Category:Western writers about Russia rename, with the second one going to Category:Writers about the Soviet Union. – June 3
Category:WFUNA Lithograph Program delete June 6
Category:Wikipedia featured portal contributors delete as WP:SOFTDELETE. – June 17
Category:Wikipedia featured sound contributors delete as WP:SOFTDELETE. – June 17
Category:Wikipedia requested images of Nickelodeon delete (non-admin closure) June 20
Category:Wikipedia requested photographs of Nickelodeon delete (non-admin closure) June 11
Category:Wikipedia requested photographs of television programs merge (non-admin closure) June 11
Category:Wikipedians in the Editor Assistance Project delete June 10
Category:Wikipedians who do not give the WMF permission to relicense their contributions delete June 21
Category:Wikipedians who like Mass Effect delete (non-admin closure) June 23
Category:Women governors and heads of sub-national entities by country withdrawn (non-admin closure) June 2
Category:Women's association football goalkeepers who have scored delete June 15
Works about Interpol rename (non-admin closure) June 24
Category:Works about the 1923 Great Kantō earthquake merge (non-admin closure) June 18
Category:Works about Typhoon Haiyan merge (non-admin closure) June 18