| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:1897 by day |
Delete |
October 22
|
| Category:1988 Births |
delete. – |
October 23
|
| 2008–14 MISL team articles |
rename |
October 3
|
| Category:2016 in Canadian sport |
speedy redirected. No prejudice against a comprehensive discussion if anyone feels that all of the sibling categories should be at "sport" instead of "sports", but as long as they are at "sports" this one needs to follow suit |
October 7
|
| Category:5 percenter Wikipedians |
delete. – |
October 14
|
| Category:ABU Song Festivals 2012 |
delete |
October 22
|
| Category:ABU Song Festivals 2014 |
delete |
October 22
|
| Category:Academy Special Achievement Award winners |
rename |
October 24
|
| Category:Active South Korean girl groups |
merge |
October 23
|
| Category:Advocates of responsible parenting being promoted by governments |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:Albuquerque Sol FC seasons |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:American Anglican bishops |
Rename |
October 1
|
| Category:American dissidents |
delete |
October 15
|
| Category:American Eagle Outfitters |
Delete |
October 25
|
| Category:American people of Persian-Jewish descent |
rename |
October 6
|
| Category:American politicians |
do not rename. I also note that the category was not tagged with Template:Cfr during this discussion |
October 4
|
| Category:Anime articles needing expert attention |
delete |
October 28
|
| Category:Arsenium and Natalia Gordienko songs |
split. (This seems to have been implemented already as the category is empty.) – |
October 19
|
| Category:Athletics (track and field) national champions |
rename |
October 20
|
| Category:Awesome Wikipedians |
No consensus |
October 11
|
| Category:Baptist ministers from the United States |
withdrawn |
October 4
|
| Category:Biggest names in the Business |
delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Birdlife International national partners |
delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Bishops of Jamaica |
Rename to Category:Anglican bishops in Jamaica. There is a consensus to rename, but the issue in choosing in/of is not clear. Based on the suggestion below that Category:Bishops in Jamaica be the parent, if I read the replies correctly, it should follow that name. If there is a substantial objection to my logic we can have a new nomination to only discuss the two letters. This rename fixes the more important larger problem |
October 1
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Brighton, New York |
rename |
October 25
|
| Category:California soccer teams |
rename |
October 6
|
| Category:CFR Cluj players |
merge |
October 16
|
| Category:Church History |
delete, without prejudice to future re-development of a historiography-related category under a similar name |
October 31
|
| Category:Churches in Romania by denomination |
merge |
October 3
|
| Category:Compositions by Hamsalekha |
rename |
October 29
|
| Category:Compositions by V. Harikrishna |
Rename |
October 1
|
| Category:Computer-animated sequel films |
delete and upmerge contents to Category:Computer-animated films and Category:Sequel films |
October 20
|
| Category:Corsica football clubs |
rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Creative Commons Attribution License |
Rename to Category:Wikipedians contributing under CC BY-SA and so on |
October 15
|
| Category:Distant galaxies |
delete; merge content to Category:Galaxies |
October 8
|
| Category:Dj Trevi |
delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Eco-friendly users |
Delete (NAC) |
October 12
|
| Category:Electors of Trier |
rename |
October 5
|
| Category:Eurovision Young Musicians by year |
nomination withdrawn since the articles in question have been recatted in a way that the structure now makes sense |
October 13
|
| Category:Expressways in Faridabad |
Upmerge |
October 29
|
| Category:Fellows of Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics |
rename. – |
October 20
|
| Category:Fictional doctors |
rename to Category:Fictional physicians, noting that Category:Fictional surgeons already exists. Category:Fictional medical doctors can be a redirect |
October 23
|
| Category:Fictional linguists |
no consensus, and so outdated that no further participation or consensus is likely to emerge at this point. No prejudice against relisting for a new discussion if desired |
October 9
|
| Category:Footballers' wives and girlfriends |
no consensus to delete |
October 17
|
| Category:FOX animated universe |
delete |
October 4
|
| Category:Geology literature |
Nomination withdrawn |
October 1
|
| Category:Georgian-era films |
delete |
October 22
|
| Category:History of the Islamic State (caliphate) |
delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Hudson Tubes |
Delete (equivalent to upmerge) (NAC) |
October 30
|
| Category:Iceland at sports competitions |
merge |
October 19
|
| Category:Inactive South Korean boy bands |
merge |
October 24
|
| Category:Inactive South Korean girl groups |
merge |
October 23
|
| Category:International Association for the Protection of Civilian Arms Rights Members |
delete |
October 4
|
| Category:Interracial romance films |
rename; there's also consensus to prune the contents of the category to those for which the interracial nature of the romance is significant. The pruning won't be carried out as part of this close, but any user can work on it |
October 20
|
| Category:Klark Kent albums |
rename |
October 23
|
| Category:Land animals |
Delete. A side note, if user continues to create 'bad' categories, they need to receive formal warnings on their talk page to get an administrator to take action. So if the creation of suspect categories continues, please leave formal warnings to make administrator follow up likely. Feel free to nominate other categories that are considered to be 'bad' for discussion |
October 27
|
| Category:LGBT-related albums |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:Lists of textile mills by geographical location |
merge |
October 2
|
| Category:Lucky Ali |
delete. – |
October 19
|
| Major Indoor Soccer League (2008–) categories |
rename to Category:Major Indoor Soccer League (2008–14) etc. |
October 3
|
| Category:Male film director from Telangana |
delete |
October 13
|
| Category:Manchester Wikipedia's ambassadors to other nations |
Speedy deletion under WP:CSD#G7 (Author requests deletion). Did it not occur to you, |
October 14
|
| Category:Medieval England articles by quality |
wrong place |
October 28
|
| Category:Members of the Cistercian Order by nationality |
rename. I note that this also matches the parent category Category:Cistercians |
October 4
|
| Category:Methanol epidemic poisonings |
rename |
October 7
|
| Category:National Register of Historic Places in Apomattox County, Virginia |
administrative close; already deleted/merged |
October 22
|
| Category:New York City Region, New York Registered Historic Place stubs |
rename |
October 19
|
| Category:Night Games at Michigan Stadium |
Delete (NAC) |
October 11
|
| Category:Off-price department stores of the United States |
upmerge to Category:Department stores of the United States and Category:Discount stores of the United States. Individual exceptions to the double upmerging can be worked out individually. |
October 17
|
| Category:Organization categories to adjust |
delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Organizations whose agendas relate to reproductive rights |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:People from Birtnagar |
G7 speedy delete |
October 18
|
| Category:People killed by the United States Armed Forces |
delete |
October 21
|
| Category:People on the autistic spectrum |
Rename. I did not see an effort to rename the article as suggested below, so this should move forward. If someone later decides to get the article renamed we can reconsider this name |
October 1
|
| Category:Philosophical films |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:Places in Canada with Aboriginal majority populations |
delete |
October 14
|
| Pre-Roman Gaul |
rename |
October 3
|
| Category:Pregnancy Categories |
delete |
October 13
|
| Category:Prelates |
merge |
October 3
|
| Category:Prince-Bishops of Germany |
merge |
October 5
|
| Category:Protestant clergy |
rename |
October 18
|
| Category:Recipients of the Andrei Sakharov Freedom Award |
delete |
October 14
|
| Category:Rochester area high schools |
Rename |
October 25
|
| Category:Roman Catholic bishops in Mexico |
Withdrawn |
October 1
|
| Category:Royalties |
delete. – |
October 20
|
| Category:Seismology and earthquake terminology |
merge |
October 19
|
| Category:Siena Medal recipients |
delete |
October 14
|
| Category:Small Wikipedia template categories |
Delete |
October 20
|
| Category:South Tyrolean nationalist |
Rename |
October 24
|
| Suicides by firearm in California by county |
merge |
October 14
|
| Category:SVG logos associated with health care |
merge |
October 4
|
| Category:Swedish eccentrics |
delete |
October 8
|
| Category:Thelonious Monk solo albums |
merge |
October 26
|
| Category:Thimerosal controversy |
rename |
October 24
|
| Category:Three Kingdoms in popular culture |
rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Time Quartet |
rename |
October 4
|
| Category:Transport in Palestine |
rename |
October 17
|
| Category:Ukrainian national liberation |
rename |
October 18
|
| Category:United States Speedy Trial Act case law |
upmerge. – |
October 11
|
| Category:Upcoming Indian films |
merge to Category:Upcoming films |
October 26
|
| Category:User rw-0 |
delete category. Only stub templates should be deleted at CfD. – |
October 12
|
| Category:User:ThinkLordUK |
delete. – |
October 23
|
| Category:Washington Registered Historic Place stubs |
rename |
October 3
|
| Category:Western Reserve |
delete for now; may be re-created under a different name if there is a main article written about topic, but there is general agreement that categorization of every county within the area is overcategorization |
October 30
|
| Category:Wikimedia licensing permissions |
rename |
October 3
|
| Category:Wikipedia articles incorporating text CNX Anatomy & Physiology |
Delete |
October 27
|
| Category:Wikipedia featured portals in other languages (French) |
delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Wikipedians by skin (and subcategories) |
keep. – |
October 11
|
| Category:Wikipedians in favor of secularism |
Delete (NAC) |
October 12
|
| Category:Wikipedians under investigation by the Categories Police |
delete. – |
October 11
|
| Category:Wikipedians who are enemies of control/personality freaks |
Delete (NAC) |
October 12
|
| Category:Wikipedians who have pledged to NoSeptember's Leaving statement |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:Windmills in Anglesey |
merge as nominated to both categories |
October 4
|
| Category:Yusuf Islam albums |
Keep |
October 25
|
