| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:18th-century & 19th-century English opera singers |
merge (non-admin closure) |
June 12
|
| Category:20th century in Santa Barbara, California |
merge Category:20th century in Santa Barbara, California to Category:20th century in California and Category:History of Santa Barbara, California, otherwise delete |
June 16
|
| Category:20th-century Soviet sculptors |
delete (non-admin closure) |
June 18
|
| Category:21st-century executions by Korea |
rename |
June 5
|
| Category:21st-century heads of state of France |
no consensus |
June 19
|
| Category:2nd-millennium disestablishments in Greenland |
delete |
June 24
|
| Category:5th century in France |
rename to Category:5th century in sub-Roman Gaul |
June 1
|
| Category:5th-century French people |
merge/rename as nominated, any further changes should be proposed in new nominations |
June 22
|
| 7th century in Spain |
merge/delete |
June 4
|
| Category:A Woman of the Century |
delete |
June 29
|
| Category:Abandoned country portals |
keep for now. It may be helpful to create a template that populates this category, or incorporate it via a new parameter in {{Portal maintenance status}}. – |
June 1
|
| Category:Abdullah Ibrahim |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Academics of the University of Cape Coast |
merge as nominated. This may be re-nominated for renaming along with siblings, subject to evidence of local usage. – |
June 29
|
| Category:Academics of the University of Ghana |
merge as nominated. This may be re-nominated for renaming along with siblings, subject to evidence of local usage. – |
June 29
|
| Category:Adaptations of works by Philip Wylie |
delete (non-admin closure) |
June 1
|
| Category:Adult animation studios |
keep |
June 11
|
| Category:Airports named after Artists |
delete (non-admin closure) |
June 21
|
| Category:Alabama Academy of Honor members |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
| Category:Alien abduction phenomenon |
rename. (non-admin closure) |
June 15
|
| Category:Alien abduction researchers |
merge to Category:Ufologists. Note: the only current member not also listed at Alien_abduction#Notable_figures is Timothy Good. – |
June 28
|
| Category:Alieu Ebrima Cham Joof |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Amanda Black |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Ambazonia stubs |
delete, merging to Cameroon stubs by replacing Ambazonia-stub template with two new regional stub templates. – |
June 1
|
| Category:American child celebrities |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:American cult movies |
speedy delete (G4) |
June 13
|
| Category:American federal health officials |
merge (non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
| Category:American nobility |
delete. I'll put this on the manual page in case anyone wants to make a list |
June 29
|
| Category:American peers |
delete. I'll put this on the manual page in case anyone wants to make a list |
June 29
|
| Category:American princesses |
delete. I'll put this on the manual page in case anyone wants to make a list |
June 29
|
| Category:American twin actresses |
delete |
June 20
|
| Category:Anti-Muslim sentiment |
no consensus. I suggest that the next step should be a {{subst:Cfd|type=Restructure}} CFD discussion on the structure, proposing (i) definitions of scope for each of the three categories, and (ii) which should be the parent of which others. – |
June 4
|
| Category:Antonovych Prize winners |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
| Category:Australian anesthesiologists |
rename |
June 21
|
| Category:Backing vocalists |
delete |
June 30
|
| Category:Bella Thorne |
delete |
June 27
|
| Category:Berkeley Open Infrastructure for Network Computing Projects |
speedy merge WP:C2A. – |
June 11
|
| Category:Billie Eilish |
delete |
June 21
|
| Binghamton Crickets |
rename; the arguments against it seem to be misunderstandings and have been refuted. – |
June 22
|
| Category:Bradenton–Sarasota–Venice metropolitan area |
rename |
June 25
|
| Category:Breakthrough Prize winners |
delete |
June 6
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Chełm |
merge |
June 1
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Comayagua |
merge |
June 1
|
| Category:Burgundian saints |
delete |
June 30
|
| Category:Businesspeople in advertising by nationality |
rename. – |
June 1
|
| Category:Calixa-Lavallée Award winners |
delete |
June 8
|
| Category:Calixa-Lavallée Award |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
| Category:Cardi B |
delete |
June 27
|
| Category:Cars powered by rear-mounted 5-cylinder engines |
no consensus. Editors are welcome to make a broader nomination. – |
June 9
|
| Category:Catholic dioceses in India |
split |
June 28
|
| Centuries in Hispania |
rename (including the Portugal categories, which are not merged to Category:Medieval Portugal) |
June 4
|
| Championship-winning seasons |
rename |
June 13
|
| Category:Chubbuck, Idaho |
merge to Category:Pocatello metropolitan area manually |
June 29
|
| Church buildings, inconsistent categories |
rename |
June 15
|
| Churches |
merge for now (as WP:SOFTDELETE) except for group 4 and Category:Churches in Düsseldorf, Category:Churches in Osnabrück, Category:Churches in Limassol, Category:Churches in Plzeň, Category:Churches in Darmstadt, Category:Churches in Leeuwarden, Category:Churches in Weimar; Category:Churches in Lucknow, Category:Churches in Mysore, Category:Churches in Pune, Category:Churches in Srinagar, Category:Churches in Jaffna, Category:Churches in Banja Luka, Category:Churches in Batumi, Category:Churches in Agartala. – |
June 19
|
| Category:Civic Movement – Tricolour |
rename to Category:Tricolour Citizens' Movement |
June 20
|
| Category:Coffee table books |
keep |
June 15
|
| Companies by millennium |
delete all |
June 15
|
| Category:Company owned by a blind CEO |
delete (non-admin closure) |
June 24
|
| Category:Computer hardware companies |
do not merge |
June 10
|
| Category:Condominium builders |
delete. The 1 article in the category is Harry Stinson, should anyone want to recategorize it. (non-admin closure) |
June 10
|
| Category:Confucius Peace Prize recipients |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Confucius Peace Prize |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Countesses of Barcelona |
keep |
June 8
|
| Category:County of Aragon |
rename |
June 8
|
| Category:Dancing with the Stars (American TV series) participants |
speedily deleted. – |
June 1
|
| Category:Dermatology societies |
rename |
June 7
|
| Category:Descendants of Qian Liu |
delete. – |
June 9
|
| Descent by Spanish region |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
| Category:Dhallywood |
merge, potentially could have been speedied per WP:C2D, (non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
| Category:Dutch people of Pakistani Punjabi descent |
delete |
June 10
|
| Early medieval Spanish people |
rename or merge as indicated |
June 26
|
| Category:Easter traditions |
no action necessary |
June 9
|
| Category:Elle King |
delete |
June 21
|
| Encyclopedias by language |
no consensus. – |
June 15
|
| Category:Fairies or sprites in video games |
merge to Category:Fantasy video games (non-admin closure) |
June 11
|
| Category:Fellows of former colleges and halls of the University of Oxford |
delete |
June 25
|
| Category:Female Americans |
merge |
June 20
|
| Festivals |
delete, per precedent |
June 29
|
| Category:Film scores by composer |
do not rename |
June 16
|
| Category:First Ladies and Gentlemen of California |
no consensus/wait |
June 11
|
| Category:Five Nights at Freddy's (series) |
rename |
June 13
|
| Category:Flags by issue |
rename to Category:Flags by subject |
June 15
|
| Category:Football in the Caribbean part of the Kingdom of the Netherlands |
rename |
June 29
|
| Category:Gamebryo engine games |
rename |
June 24
|
| Category:GameMaker: Studio games |
rename |
June 12
|
| Category:Games made with RPG Maker |
rename |
June 21
|
| Category:Games Workshop Worldwide Campaigns |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 1
|
| Category:GoldSrc engine games |
rename |
June 24
|
| Category:Health care companies by millennium of establishment |
delete |
June 6
|
| Category:History of food |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
| Category:House de Rouvroy |
rename |
June 10
|
| Category:Hunter: The Reckoning video games |
merge per the extended proposal |
June 16
|
| Category:HVAC manufacturing companies |
rename to Category:Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning companies |
June 29
|
| Category:Infobox NFL biography with disambiguated name |
category has already been deleted per WP:G7. (non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
| Category:Intersectional LGBT topics |
merge |
June 9
|
| Category:Intersex actresses |
merge. to Category:Intersex people (non-admin closure) |
June 12
|
| Islam and Muslim user templates |
merge but do not rename |
June 26
|
| Category:Jaakko Löytty |
delete |
June 21
|
| Japan |
rename |
June 11
|
| Category:Jenni Vartiainen |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Jewish South African anti-apartheid activists |
keep |
June 15
|
| Category:Jidenna |
delete |
June 27
|
| Category:Joanna of Castile |
rename |
June 23
|
| Category:Keto acids |
keep |
June 4
|
| Category:Kindred of the East |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
| Category:KT Tunstall |
rename to Category:Works by KT Tunstall |
June 27
|
| Category:Lillian Leitzel |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
| Category:Mabel (singer) songs |
do not rename |
June 30
|
| Category:Magic: The Gathering players |
withdrawn. More than a week of silence is enough to convince me I can be WP:BOLD here |
June 6
|
| Category:Mandopop artists templates |
rename |
June 30
|
| Category:Manitoulin Island |
no consensus. There is redundancy here, but one set is part of categories by island, and the other is part of categories by census division. Both hierarchies have their uses. This is one of many cases where our practice of building categories by more than one criterion results in one layer holding only a sub-cat that's part of another layer. – |
June 15
|
| Category:MAZ buses |
merge |
June 29
|
| Medieval Finland |
keep/do not merge |
June 30
|
| Category:Members of the Fabian Society Executive Committee |
merge to Category:Members of the Fabian Society. – |
June 22
|
| Category:Meneses Monroy |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
June 13
|
| Category:Middle-earth horses |
keep. In terms of the discussion, this would pretty much be no consensus. However, in terms of policy-based rationales, I'm not seeing any policy being cited by the delete side. In particular, I'm not seeing any policy or guideline that proscribes categories of redirects. Several participants have cited WP:LISTRCAT which supports categories of redirects to a list and where this category is named as an example. The section has been there, along with the examples, since August 2007, and predates the previous CfD. Since we are meant to give greater weight to policy-based rationales, that makes it a slam-dunk for keep in the absence of any counter-policy. It seems obvious to me that a discussion of the LISTCRAT guideline would be required before this could be nominated again. Indeed, that should have happened before either of the CfDs for this page |
June 18
|
| Category:Miniatures games based on Middle-earth |
merge |
June 3
|
| Category:Model railroad manufacturers |
keep (non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
| Category:Monégasque people of Lorrainian descent |
delete |
June 18
|
| Category:Musers |
no consensus |
June 2
|
| Category:New Zealand portal |
merge Category:New Zealand portals to Category:New Zealand portal |
June 1
|
| Category:Northern Ireland MLAs 2016–17 |
Speedy closed as rename, C2C |
June 8
|
| Office television series |
merge |
June 18
|
| Category:Operating system user templates/Macintosh |
rename |
June 30
|
| Organisations based in Golaghat |
merge/delete (non-admin closure) |
June 7
|
| Organisations based in Greenland |
Withdrawn by nominator |
June 24
|
| Organisations based in Haiti |
rename using z (option A). – |
June 23
|
| Organisations based in Iraq |
rename as needed, to "organizations" (option A) |
June 22
|
| Organizations based in East Timor |
rename per option A |
June 23
|
| Category:Pablo Today Records albums |
merge |
June 29
|
| Category:Papua Region |
rename to Category:Southern Region, Papua New Guinea |
June 30
|
| Category:People associated with Alieu Ebrima Cham Joof |
delete |
June 10
|
| Category:People associated with the 2020 United States presidential election |
delete |
June 9
|
| Category:People associated with William Blake |
delete |
June 10
|
| Category:People by cultural region in Latvia |
merge as nominated |
June 9
|
| People by nationality and status |
merge all. (non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
| People from Sardinia |
please renominate Category:Sardinian Roman Catholic priests for renaming, delete everything else |
June 19
|
| Category:People from Singapore |
no consensus. (non-admin closure) |
June 15
|
| Category:People from Sunnmøre |
keep |
June 30
|
| Category:People of Italic descent |
delete |
June 24
|
| Category:People of the Revolt of the Comuneros |
speedy keep. Withdrawn |
June 26
|
| Category:People relating to Anne Frank |
delete |
June 10
|
| Category:People who follow a straight edge lifestyle |
delete |
June 9
|
| Category:Philippine tragicomedy films |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:Places named after Thomas Jefferson |
delete |
June 19
|
| Category:Planned science and education developments |
soft delete. – |
June 28
|
| Category:Poker companies |
keep (non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
| Category:Polish popes |
keep |
June 7
|
| Category:Political correctness |
do not simply delete; a further nomination is needed to seek consensus on what should replace it. In case it helps, I have listed the current contents at Wikipedia talk:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 June 9. – |
June 9
|
| Populated places established by year |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
| Category:Post–World War II forced migrations in Europe |
merge |
June 11
|
| Category:Potentially illegible userboxes |
rename |
June 18
|
| Category:Powers of Two |
moot (non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
| Category:Prison governors by country |
rename |
June 1
|
| Category:Prison officials |
keep (non-admin closure) |
June 1
|
| Category:Project Steve |
delete |
June 13
|
| Category:Recipients of the Benson Medal |
delete |
June 28
|
| Religion in France by city |
merge |
June 15
|
| Category:Religion in France by city |
merge |
June 19
|
| Category:Religion in Poland by city |
no consensus. Repeat nominations are discouraged for at least 1 year, as some defenders of the category emphasised the potential for growth. – |
June 21
|
| Category:Religion in the Arab world by city |
no consensus |
June 23
|
| Category:Ren'Py games and visual novels |
rename |
June 13
|
| Category:Robert Bloch |
delete per WP:OCEPON. Where there are many articles for works but they are all in sub-categories for works, this does not justify an eponymous category, but rather means that it is not needed, if there are no other biography-related articles. – |
June 23
|
| Category:Roman Catholic dioceses in India |
rename |
June 19
|
| Category:Rowers from Toronto |
keep |
June 2
|
| Category:Russian city of residence user templates |
rename |
June 27
|
| Category:Sanctum (series) |
delete (non-admin closure) |
June 13
|
| Category:Sarabha tribe |
delete |
June 3
|
| Category:Scientific organizations by country |
no consensus |
June 28
|
| Category:Scottish peoples |
delete |
June 23
|
| Category:Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders |
delete |
June 25
|
| Category:Screenplays by writer |
rename to Films with screenplays by X |
June 16
|
| Serbia |
rename all. (non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
| Category:Serfs |
do not merge |
June 16
|
| Category:Sinéad O'Connor |
No consensus |
June 22
|
| Category:Snooker organizations |
Renamed. I requested the rename to 'Snooker organizations' via speedy a few days ago. As this has now been opposed I am reverting myself |
June 26
|
| Category:Specialty vehicle manufacturers of Greece |
merge |
June 29
|
| Category:Sports in Chestnut Hill |
delete |
June 10
|
| Category:Sports originating by decade |
categories empty → delete |
June 2
|
| Category:Sportspeople from Walkertown, North Carolina |
merge to Category:People from Forsyth County, North Carolina. Note that the one article is already in Category:Softball players from North Carolina, so there is no need for a dual merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
| Category:Spouses of Prime Ministers of New Zealand |
no consensus/wait |
June 11
|
| St. Louis Commissioner of Police |
merge and rename per option F (non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
| Category:Stacy (singer) |
delete |
June 7
|
| Category:Strathmore University academics |
do not rename |
June 2
|
| Suebian kings of Galicia |
rename |
June 9
|
| Category:Summer camps in fiction |
rename |
June 24
|
| Category:Summer camps in films |
rename |
June 24
|
| Category:Superhero film directors |
delete |
June 30
|
| Category:Television series based on Internet properties |
rename |
June 2
|
| Category:Tenali Rama |
keep, matching main article after RM. – |
June 1
|
| Category:The Disciples of Apocalypse |
no consensus |
June 22
|
| Category:The Larry Sanders Show |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
June 1
|
| Category:The Office (UK TV series) episodes |
merge Category:The Office (British TV series) episodes (the new name for the nominated category) to Category:The Office (British TV series) |
June 22
|
| Category:Tig Notaro |
keep |
June 23
|
| Category:Tigran Hamasyan |
category has already been deleted per WP:G7. (non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
| Category:Time travelers in film |
no consensus to delete all, so merge but purging members where this is not defining for the character. This will include the new categories linked at the end of this discussion. – |
June 4
|
| Category:Top Chef judges |
delete |
June 21
|
| Category:U.S. Army installations named for Confederate soldiers |
keep. – |
June 23
|
| U.S. presidential primaries |
rename all. (non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
| Ukraine |
Option A – rename using "z". There is consensus to make a change in order to achieve consistency, but opinions on which way to go are finely balanced. To be consistent with the precedent for France (which was also closed by me), I am giving weight to the spelling used on the national government websites. – |
June 19
|
| Category:United States Department of Homeland Security images |
merge to Category:United States government images. (non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
| Category:University and college chancellors by country |
rename to Heads of X |
June 28
|
| Category:Userbox galleries |
closed awaiting a fresh and better structured discussion (non-admin closure) |
June 30
|
| Category:Vampire: The Eternal Struggle |
merge |
June 30
|
| Category:Vampire: The Requiem |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
| Category:Venezuela solidarity activists |
delete |
June 22
|
| Category:Video game fan user templates |
merge (non-admin closure) |
June 12
|
| Category:Video games based on Bone (comics) |
merge |
June 28
|
| Category:Virumaa |
delete |
June 6
|
| Category:Vista Broadcast Group radio stations |
rename |
June 21
|
| Category:Vivaldi (web browser) |
relisted, see here (non-admin closure) |
June 29
|
| Category:Web series genres |
rename (non-admin closure) |
June 28
|
| Category:Wikipedians who use Chromebook |
delete |
June 8
|
| Category:William Goldman |
delete. Although some editors want to keep it, policy supports deletion. It is sufficient for navigation that William Goldman, Category:Works by William Goldman and Category:Films based on works by William Goldman are interlinked; there is no other content. – |
June 23
|
| Category:William Tryon |
delete (non-admin closure) |
June 15
|
| Category:Works by Bella Thorne |
keep |
June 27
|
| Category:Writers who blog |
delete |
June 16
|
| Category:XnGine engine games |
rename |
June 24
|
| Category:Zoological Societies |
speedy rename WP:C2A. – |
June 9
|
