| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:2018 Commonwealth Games sports templates |
keep |
October 12
|
| Category:Adaptive clothing companies of Canada |
delete |
October 4
|
| Category:Adaptive clothing companies |
rename as WP:SOFTDELETE, i.e. without prejudice to re-creating if and when this would be useful. – |
October 4
|
| Category:Advocacy groups by continent |
no consensus |
October 21
|
| Category:Alt-lite |
merge |
October 30
|
| Category:AMERICANS |
speedy delete WP:C2C, etc. – |
October 5
|
| Category:Anarchists by occupation |
delete |
October 21
|
| Category:Angelina Jolie |
delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Animals described in the 1750s |
delete |
October 3
|
| Category:Anti-nationalists |
delete |
October 30
|
| Category:Archaea described in the 1920s |
Upmerge/Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Asian superheroes |
no consensus: though there may be consensus if a broader nomination in brought. The opposition was procedural. FWIW, the category was deleted 10 years ago |
October 29
|
| Category:Automobiles |
rename |
October 10
|
| Category:Bacteria described in the 1780s |
delete |
October 8
|
| Category:Basshunter singles covers |
merge |
October 21
|
| Category:BBC America shows |
Rename |
October 31
|
| Category:Beast (Canadian band) members |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Beetles of Great Britain |
merge |
October 10
|
| Category:Best Girl |
Delete |
October 22
|
| Category:Biographical films about Butch Cassidy's Wild Bunch |
merge |
October 6
|
| Category:BioWare companions |
 Relisted at 2018 NOV 5 CFD |
October 23
|
| Category:BioWare companions |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 23 CFD |
October 12
|
| Category:BioWare companions |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 October 12#Category:BioWare companions |
October 3
|
| Category:Birds of the British Isles |
Merge |
October 3
|
| Category:Birds of the Miombo |
Merge |
October 11
|
| Category:Birmingham Bears cricketers |
merge |
October 10
|
| Category:Bitcoin Cash |
delete |
October 15
|
| Category:Bridge-tunnels |
rename |
October 2
|
| Category:C. Wright Mills |
keep. – |
October 23
|
| Category:C. Wright Mills |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 23 CFD |
October 15
|
| Calendars of Asian countries |
no consensus |
October 20
|
| Calendars of Indian regions |
merge |
October 20
|
| Category:Cambodia football navigational boxes |
merge |
October 4
|
| Category:Canadian journalists of Chinese descent |
no consensus: but it looks like there may be consensus if a broader discussion or nomination addresses this and similar categories. The opposition was largely procedural rather than substantive |
October 29
|
| Category:Cars |
No Consensus to rename - |
October 26
|
| Category:Castles in Germany by region |
no consensus. The main confusion is why the proposal is to delete the container category but keep the subcategories that divide castles by region. A fresh nomination that deletes all of them could be preferable. |
October 11
|
| Category:Catholic Church offices |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 November 1#Category:Catholic Church offices |
October 17
|
| Category:Catholic Church offices |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 October 17#Category:Catholic Church offices |
October 8
|
| Category:Chutiya kingdom |
delete; merge contents to Category:History of Assam |
October 25
|
| Category:Classical Israel |
split |
October 15
|
| Category:Classical Palestine |
Relisted at 2018 NOV 6 CFD. |
October 23
|
| Category:Classical Syria |
Relisted at 2018 NOV 6 CFD |
October 23
|
| Category:Companies by city in the Netherlands |
keep |
October 2
|
| Companies by country and city |
Rename |
October 11
|
| Conflicts by millennium, century and decade up to 1000 AD |
No consensus |
October 15
|
| Conflicts by millennium, century and decade up to 1000 AD |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 15 CFD |
October 7
|
| Category:Conversion therapy organizations |
keep |
October 14
|
| Category:Cultural depictions of people |
containerize, as proposed. I will leave the implementation of this to the participants in the discussion |
October 16
|
| Category:Cultural depictions of people |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 16 CFD |
October 6
|
| Category:Daily newspapers published by Community Newspaper Holdings |
rename |
October 4
|
| Category:Daredevil seasons |
no consensus to merge, but rename to Category:Daredevil (TV series) seasons. |
October 23
|
| Category:Daredevil seasons |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 23 CFD |
October 13
|
| Category:Defunct organisations |
rename as modified |
October 24
|
| Category:Destroyed landmarks in Spain demolished by period |
rename |
October 15
|
| Category:Directors |
no consensus |
October 31
|
| Category:Districts of East Timor (etc) |
rename |
October 29
|
| Category:E-commerce in the United States |
merge |
October 4
|
| English districts |
No consensus. The article name is a problem but can't be resolved here. A new RM then a follow-up CFD to match the article name seems the best way forward |
October 28
|
| Category:ESports games |
Rename nominated categories. Others will need to be listed to be processed; they can be done at WP:CFDS |
October 17
|
| Category:Establishments in Lower Burma by year |
merge |
October 10
|
| Category:Executed Widerstand Catholics |
Merge |
October 18
|
| Category:False writing systems |
delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Fictional filicides |
do not rename |
October 1
|
| Category:Fictional regicides |
do not rename |
October 1
|
| Category:Fictional suicides |
do not rename |
October 1
|
| Category:Films about criminals |
keep. – |
October 23
|
| Category:Films featured in Mystery Science Theater 3000 episodes |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:Films shot in the Czech Republic |
do not rename, without prejudice to a creation of Category:Films shot in Czechoslovakia |
October 15
|
| Foo in media |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Foo in media |
Rename |
October 23
|
| Category:Football managers who never became players |
delete |
October 13
|
| Category:Footballers playing in Australia |
delete; contents appear to be appropriately categorized elsewhere |
October 4
|
| Category:Former capitals of Arkansas |
merge |
October 30
|
| Category:Foxhound packs of the United Kingdom |
merge |
October 15
|
| Category:Fungi described in the 1750s |
delete |
October 13
|
| Government agencies of Barbados |
merge and rename to Category:Government agencies of Barbados. – |
October 31
|
| Category:Hakka songs |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Hindu movements and organisations |
merge |
October 27
|
| Category:Hindu saints |
do not merge |
October 25
|
| Category:Historic hotels in the United States |
Relisted at 2018 NOV 5 CFD |
October 19
|
| Category:History of the Aztec civilization |
rename/merge |
October 19
|
| Category:Holy orders in the Catholic Church |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 November 1#Category:Holy orders in the Catholic Church |
October 17
|
| Category:Humane societies in Canada |
merge and delete as nominated |
October 5
|
| Category:Hungarian Reform rabbis |
keep |
October 9
|
| Category:International Society for Krishna Consciousness bands |
No consensus |
October 16
|
| Category:International Society for Krishna Consciousness bands |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 16 CFD |
October 4
|
| Category:International sports federations |
Rename |
October 18
|
| Category:Islamic terrorism in fiction |
no consensus |
October 29
|
| Category:Jack Nicholson |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:Jessica Jones seasons |
merge as nominated, and also to Category:Marvel Cinematic Universe seasons |
October 12
|
| Category:Jewish communism |
rename to Category:Jewish communist movements |
October 11
|
| Category:Jewish Czechoslovak history |
merge |
October 5
|
| Category:Landlocked U.S. states |
Delete - |
October 31
|
| Category:Late ancient Christianity |
rename |
October 19
|
| Category:Legislators who represented multiple jurisdictions |
delete |
October 15
|
| Category:Lepidoptera described in 1758 |
delete |
October 12
|
| Category:Lighthouses in Kollam |
merge as nominated and to Category:Buildings and structures in Kollam |
October 27
|
| Category:List of armed conflicts in 2014 |
speedy rename pluralization per C2A |
October 5
|
| Category:List of Bulgarian-language publishers |
Merge |
October 9
|
| Category:List of International Civil Societies |
Delete |
October 9
|
| Category:List of stadiums in China |
merge |
October 9
|
| Category:List of tide gauges |
merge |
October 9
|
| Category:Lists of American crime drama television series episodes |
do not merge |
October 24
|
| Category:Lists of people by association |
do not merge |
October 24
|
| Category:Lists of people by association |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 October 24#Category:Lists of people by association |
October 13
|
| Category:Lists of people by institutional affiliation |
merge |
October 13
|
| Category:Literary genres based on writers' names |
delete |
October 14
|
| Category:London protocols |
Delete |
October 16
|
| Category:Lübeck law |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:Marin Gaupalika |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Mario Universe games |
Move to Category:Mario video games. Nomination withdrawn. (non-admin closure) |
October 10
|
| Medieval Ireland |
no consensus |
October 7
|
| Minor planets by source of name |
I do not feel that I can close this discussion as anything other than keep. That said, as noted, this may be a case of WP:LOCALCONSENSUS, since WP:SHAREDNAME at least seems directly on point. There are, of course, exceptions to every rule or guideline. It would help to gain a broader consensus that this is a scheme that needs to be excepted from those general guidelines with prima facie apply. |
October 26
|
| Category:Months in the 2000s |
relisted with 2 siblings at 2018 November 19. – |
October 23
|
| Category:Months in the 2000s |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 23 CFD |
October 12
|
| Music organisations by country |
Rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Neural networks |
split into Category:Neural circuits and Category:Artificial neural networks. Keep Category:Neural networks as a parent category. |
October 28
|
| Category:Neurological disease deaths in New York (state) |
Upmerge |
October 16
|
| Category:New Zealand One Day International captains |
keep per DENY. NPASR if an editor in good standing agrees with nomination rationale |
October 20
|
| Category:New Zealand Twenty20 International captains |
keep per DENY. NPASR if an editor in good standing agrees with nomination rationale |
October 20
|
| Category:Non-Gregorian observances by Gregorian month |
manually disperse the contents |
October 16
|
| Category:Non-Gregorian observances by Gregorian month |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 16 CFD |
October 6
|
| Observances by calendar |
withdrawn/no consensus |
October 7
|
| Category:Observances set by the Coptic calendar |
merge |
October 21
|
| Category:Observances set by the Ethiopian calendar |
merge |
October 21
|
| Category:Observances set by the Hebrew calendar |
merge |
October 21
|
| Category:Organisations based in the European Union |
Relisted at 2018 NOV 6 CFD |
October 18
|
| Category:Organizations based in Sweden |
rename to option A |
October 25
|
| Category:Parks in Barisal |
merge |
October 19
|
| Category:People associated with Bitcoin Cash |
merge |
October 15
|
| Category:People associated with bribery |
Merge/delete |
October 17
|
| Category:People associated with Chatham House |
rename, and no problem with purging the contents as appropriate |
October 4
|
| Category:People associated with chocolate |
delete |
October 8
|
| Category:People associated with EOS |
merge |
October 15
|
| Category:People associated with musical groups |
delete |
October 30
|
| Category:People associated with oil shale |
Relisted at 2018 NOV 6 CFD |
October 19
|
| Category:People associated with the New Deal |
merge. (@Marcocapelle:, I will ask you to purge what needs to go.) |
October 8
|
| Category:People associated with torture |
Merge |
October 9
|
| Category:People associated with Zcash |
merge |
October 15
|
| Category:People from Nickelsville, Virginia |
Merge |
October 17
|
| Category:People from Sainte-Edwidge-de-Clifton, Quebec |
merge |
October 2
|
| Category:People from Shadwell, Leeds |
rename |
October 6
|
| Category:People from Shadwell, West Yorkshire |
merge to Category:People from the City of Leeds |
October 15
|
| Category:People involved with terrorism |
Merge |
October 11
|
| People who died in the Holocaust by occupation |
merge/delete as per adjusted nomination. As discussed, these will be done manually rather than by bot |
October 13
|
| Category:People who were forced disappeared |
delete |
October 8
|
| People whose statue is in the National Statuary Hall Collection |
delete |
October 23
|
| Category:Philanthropic organisations based in Namibia |
no consensus |
October 19
|
| Category:Philanthropic organizations based in Azerbaijan |
no consensus |
October 19
|
| Category:Political pressure groups of Barbados |
Delete |
October 22
|
| Category:Poor law unions in Dorset |
merge |
October 19
|
| Category:Prayers in the Catholic Church |
rename to Category:Roman Catholic prayers |
October 7
|
| Category:Pro basketball players from Monrovia high School |
rename to Category:Monrovia High School alumni (there is consensus not to keep the category under its current purpose, and high school alumni categories are relatively common) |
October 1
|
| Category:Professional sports leagues in Lebanon |
Speedy delete per creator request |
October 6
|
| Category:Queer |
no consensus on exactly what to do, but there is consensus that something should probably change. As discussed, a widely advertised fresh discussion would probably be the best route here |
October 5
|
| Category:Railway stations served by Arriva Trains Wales |
rename to Category:Railway stations served by Transport for Wales Rail |
October 13
|
| Category:Railway stations served by Gatwick Express |
no consensus, but hopefully one will emerge from the discussion started here |
October 13
|
| Category:Railway stations served by Heathrow Connect |
Keep pending centralised discussion |
October 16
|
| Category:Rajkumar Films |
Delete |
October 1
|
| Category:Rajput chiefs |
delete |
October 15
|
| Recurring events until 1800 |
no consensus |
October 7
|
| Category:Religion in Bali |
speedy keep per WP:SKCRIT#1: withdrawn[1] by noinator |
October 6
|
| Category:REOTITH |
procedural close, meanwhile the category has been converted to an article. (non-admin closure) |
October 5
|
| Category:Resort municipalities in Prince Edward Island |
withdrawn by nominator |
October 28
|
| Category:Retail companies established in 1670 |
merge |
October 21
|
| Category:Russian people of Huguenot descent |
procedural close. The discussion was also created at Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2018 October 9. Since that is the venue for review of deletions, it would probably be best to consolidate the discussion there. Please discuss at DRV page linked. (non-admin closure) |
October 9
|
| Category:Rāja yoga |
delete |
October 26
|
| Category:Sankethi people |
no consensus |
October 6
|
| Category:Satanic ritual abuse in the United States |
Merge |
October 17
|
| Category:Satire anime and manga |
No consensus |
October 16
|
| Category:Satire anime and manga |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 16 CFD |
October 6
|
| Category:Seventh-day Adventist clergy by nationality |
Rename Category:Seventh-day Adventist clergy to Category:Seventh-day Adventist ministers; rename Category:American Seventh-day Adventist clergy to Category:American Seventh-day Adventist ministers; delete Category:Seventh-day Adventist clergy by nationality |
October 30
|
| Category:Shia Islam in fiction |
rename to Category:Order of Assassins in fiction |
October 29
|
| Category:Sidney Poitier |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:Sitcoms without laugh tracks |
Delete |
October 1
|
| Category:Social economists |
delete |
October 1
|
| Category:Soldier characters in video games |
Rename |
October 31
|
| Category:Soundtracks by century |
no consensus |
October 2
|
| Category:South Africa women's national cricket team captains |
keep per DENY. NPASR if an editor in good standing agrees with nomination rationale |
October 21
|
| Southeast Asia up to 1500 |
no consensus |
October 6
|
| Category:Sri Lanka women cricket captains |
keep per DENY. NPASR if an editor in good standing agrees with nomination rationale |
October 21
|
| Category:Sri Lankan military uniforms |
merge |
October 15
|
| Category:Star Wars droid characters |
no consensus |
October 12
|
| Category:Star Wars droid characters |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 October 12#Category:Star Wars droid characters |
October 3
|
| Category:Superhero films featuring Anti-Heroes |
delete |
October 7
|
| Teachers colleges |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 23 CFD |
October 12
|
| Teachers colleges |
merge |
October 8
|
| Category:Thai Volunteer Defense Corps Officers |
delete |
October 5
|
| Category:The Good Place episodes |
delete, as I am not aware of precedent or guidance that says 1 is sufficient for a TV episode category by series. This is a WP:SOFTDELETE, i.e. the category may be re-created if more pages are created. In practice, the category needs to be merged to Category:The Good Place, and I will add the pilot episode to another parent Category:Sitcom episodes. – |
October 18
|
| Category:The Guild (series) |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:The King of Queens characters |
keep. The argument to delete this category citing WP:SMALLCAT is contradicted by SMALLCAT itself, as it allows exceptions for those "part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme" such as this |
October 16
|
| Category:The King of Queens episodes |
keep. The argument to delete this category citing WP:SMALLCAT is contradicted by SMALLCAT itself, as it allows exceptions for those "part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme" such as this |
October 16
|
| Category:Thelemite saints |
delete |
October 20
|
| Category:Treaties signed in Switzerland |
Delete |
October 17
|
| Category:U.S. Highways by state |
do not rename |
October 10
|
| Category:UNI.T |
Delete |
October 12
|
| Category:Urban transit advocacy organisations |
Rename |
October 23
|
| Category:Uttar Pradesh Wikipedians |
no action required (non-admin closure) |
October 7
|
| Category:Vertebrates described in 1771 |
delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Vertically oriented video games |
no consensus |
October 24
|
| Category:Vice presidents of Greece |
no consensus |
October 4
|
| Villages by tehsil |
Merge |
October 17
|
| Category:Vishnuvardhan Films |
Delete |
October 1
|
| Category:White Power |
Delete |
October 12
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories named after English composers |
merge to both Category:Wikipedia categories named after British composers and Category:Wikipedia categories named after English musicians. (non-admin closure) |
October 19
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories named after Roman Catholic families |
no consensus |
October 7
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories that should not contain articles |
Relisted at 2018 OCT 23 CFD |
October 6
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories that should not contain articles |
Relisted} at 2018 NOV 6 CFD |
October 23
|
| Category:Wikipedian descendants of combat veterans |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:WikiProject Earth science participants |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:WikiProject Earth science templates |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:WikiProject Earth science |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Winter Olympic venues by year |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 October 19#Category:Winter Olympic venues by year. – |
October 7
|
| Category:Winter Olympic venues by year |
rename to ALT version specified |
October 19
|
| Category:Women cricket captains |
keep per DENY. No prejudice against renomination if someone else finds that this is a valid nomination |
October 21
|
| Category:Workhouses in Scotland |
rename |
October 19
|
| Category:World War II and the media |
reverse merge |
October 14
|
| Category:WrestleMania themes |
Delete |
October 31
|
| Years and decades in the Maya civilization |
merge |
October 7
|
| Years in Mexico |
merge as below and to Category:Aztec Empire. – |
October 7
|
| Years in the Israeli Civil Administration Area |
no consensus, though it was trending towards option D. I recommend a fresh nomination with an option or options which are clearly set out. This discussion ended up as more of a brainstorming exercise |
October 13
|
| Category:Yo-Yo Ma |
Delete |
October 11
|
