Category
Decision
Discussion_log
Category:16th-century animal births relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:16th-century_animal_births March 3
Category:1786 events of the French Revolution merge per nom and to ALT3 Category:Causes of the French Revolution .WP:INVOLVED . However, this discussion is 33 days overdue for closure, and consensus is clear, so I think that Wikipedia is better served by closing it.March 3
Category:1990s American LGBT sitcoms merge (non-admin closure ) March 28
Category:Academic pressure in Asian cultures delete redirect (non-admin closure ) March 24
Category:African-American biographical dramas keep March 17
Category:Albums recorded in a home studio no consensus March 22
Category:Alternatives to heart transplant merge (non-admin closure ) March 26
American Latter Day Saints from Missouri
delete (non-admin closure ) March 11
Category:American physicians of Armenian descent merge (non-admin closure ) March 4
Category:Amphibians of Nigeria Merge March 18
Category:Aptornithidae Merge to parent Category:Neognathae March 16
Category:Aptornithidae relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 7
Category:Armenian people from Istanbul relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Armenian_people_from_Istanbul March 8
Category:Articles with improper non-free content (lists) procedural close , category no longer exists (non-admin closure ) March 12
Category:ARU referees relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:ARU_referees March 15
Category:Aspire (political party) councillors delete (non-admin closure ) March 11
Category:Australian Collectors delete (non-admin closure ) March 22
Category:Bandy World Championship-winning players keep (non-admin closure ) March 13
Category:Bandy World Championship-winning players relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 5
Category:Barlas relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Barlas March 24
Category:Barons de Brus relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Barons_de_Brus March 23
Category:Baseball coaches from Alabama keep March 26
Category:Best companies to work for awards rename to Category:Employer awards . (non-admin closure ) March 24
Category:BHP Billiton rename March 6
Category:Black Power no consensus (non-admin closure ) March 10
Category:Black Power relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 2
Category:Bollywood content lists rename . (Yes, I am WP:INVOLVED , but this has been open 5 weeks and consensus is clear)March 3
Category:British standards merge (non-admin closure ) March 8
Category:Business and employer associations of Poland rename to Category:Business organisations based in Poland . (non-admin closure ) March 9
Cal State Hayward Pioneers football
Rename (WP:NAC ). --March 4
Category:Cannabis addiction recovery organizations merge (non-admin closure ) March 10
Carniolan culture
merge March 4
Category:Carniolan society merge to Category:Slovene dialects . It seems we agree that this is the best outcome. I'll leave the subcategorization to experts. March 3
Category:Category (grouping) delete March 7
Category:Cherokee people keep , i.e. do not rename. Note that the cat had not been taggedMarch 30
Category:Chinese teas keep March 2
Category:Class (grouping) delete March 6
Category:Community-based organizations relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Community-based_organizations March 23
Category:Competitors at multi-sport events by country keep . –March 5
Corbeta Uruguay base
mere & delete per revised nomination. –March 27
Category:Cossack raids on Ottoman Empire Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 18#Category:Cossack raids on Ottoman Empire March 10
Category:Counties of Appalachia Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 4#Category:Counties of Appalachia March 9
Category:Darude delete (non-admin closure ) March 15
Decades in Belfast
merge and delete . Likewise Category:2020s in Belfast which was created after this nomination. –March 20
Category:Department of the Government of Nepal rename (non-admin closure ) March 19
Category:Department stores of Bangkok merge/delete (non-admin closure ) March 17
Category:Depression organizations Merge to Category:Mental health organizations March 11
Category:Deuterostomes of Asia merge (non-admin closure ) March 26
Category:Deuterostomes of Japan merge (non-admin closure ) March 6
Category:Device Therapy for Heart failures delete (non-admin closure ) March 26
Category:DiMaggio family delete (non-admin closure ) March 10
Category:DiMaggio family relisted, see here March 2
Category:Directorial debut films keep (non-admin closure ) March 4
Category:Discovery Communications rename March 8
Category:Educational institutions in India keep (non-admin closure ) March 30
Elections in Ireland by year
merge March 21
Category:Emerging standards merge (non-admin closure ) March 16
Category:Emerging standards relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 8
Category:Empress Ki (TV series) delete (non-admin closure ) March 28
Category:Episcopal church buldings in Idaho speedy rename . It appeared that the relevant articles were redlinked to the target. (non-admin closure ) March 1
Category:Equivalence delete and replace with Category:Equivalence (mathematics) . (Admin note: this was implemented by purging and renaming.) –March 2
Category:Equivalent units no consensus . –March 3
Category:Ethnic Armenian lawyers Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 2#Category:Ethnic Armenian lawyers March 14
Category:Events at the 1997 European Athletics U23 Championships relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:Events_at_the_1997_European_Athletics_U23_Championships March 19
Category:Fame Academy participants Purge and upmerge per AnemoneProjectors. Pinging the participants to do the purging: @Woodensuperman , AnemoneProjectors , and Marcocapelle March 1
Category:FC Bayern Munich footballers keep March 20
Category:Fictional American people of Irish descent no consensus . This should not be brought forward again unless it is part of a nomination of all categories of fictional characters by descent. In the meantime, it might be helpful to build a visible hierarchy of those categories. –March 29
Category:Fictional Irish people by ethnic or national origin rename March 21
Category:Fictional rogue planets merge (non-admin closure ) March 17
Category:File deletion template shortcuts delete (non-admin closure ) March 18
Category:Films based on Pride and Prejudice keep (non-admin closure ) March 21
Category:Films directed by Bala (director) keep (non-admin closure ) March 28
Category:Films directed by Bala (director) relisted, see here March 20
Category:Films scored by Aadesh Shrivastav merge March 12
Category:Films shot in multiple formats delete March 19
Category:Fish of Togo merge (non-admin closure ) March 6
Category:FishCenter Live delete (non-admin closure ) March 15
Category:Formula Atlantic drivers Delete (WP:NAC ). March 19
Category:Gambits Merge March 21
Category:Gay villages in the New Jersey rename . –March 28
Category:Gender pay gap by country Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 17#Category:Gender pay gap by country March 17
Category:Great Lakes Premier League seasons delete (non-admin closure ) March 5
Category:Greek mathematics keep , i.e. do not renameMarch 16
Category:Groups connected to the Khazars relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:Groups_connected_to_the_Khazars March 24
Category:Halo factions merge (non-admin closure ) March 7
Category:Health standards no consensus March 8
Category:History of Welsh devolution rename March 15
Category:Hungarian actors in gay pornographic films merge to parent categories (non-admin closure ) March 25
Category:Immigrants to the United Kingdom from Aden no consensus to merge or delete, so rename . –
March 13
Insurance in small countries
Keep (WP:NAC ). March 30
Category:Jenny Parks delete (non-admin closure ) March 15
Category:Late Iron Age Scotland relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Late Iron Age Scotland March 8
Category:Leaders of People's Alliance of Tower Hamlets keep . Delete !voters far outnumber keep !voters, but the nominator's blatant misrepresentation of WP:SMALLCAT was accepted by most keep !voters, leaving their !votes ill-founded in policy. For the record, WP:SMALLCAT 's current version says Avoid categories that, by their very definition, will never have more than a few members, unless such categories are part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme (underlining added by me) March 11
Category:Leaders of Tower Hamlets First keep . Delete !voters far outnumber keep !voters, but the nominator's blatant misrepresentation of WP:SMALLCAT was accepted by most keep !voters, leaving their !votes ill-founded in policy. For the record, WP:SMALLCAT 's current version says Avoid categories that, by their very definition, will never have more than a few members, unless such categories are part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme (underlining added by me) March 11
Category:Leather Industry Speedy rename per WP:C2D March 4
Category:Lebanese communities outside Lebanon merge March 24
Category:Legal films keep (non-admin closure ) March 4
Category:Leucogeranus delete as empty. (non-admin closure ) March 7
Category:List of 'Star Wars' Characters Delete (WP:NAC ). --March 25
Category:List of Image Comics publications delete (non-admin closure ) March 30
Category:Lists of railway accidents in Australia rename all . Note that this discussion was originally closed inappropriately (see WP:BADNAC ) by a now-blocked non-admin sock @Artix Kreiger , who proceeded to move the pages manually. I reverted all the manual moves; full saga explained here March 27
Category:Logical fallacies rename (non-admin closure ) March 10
Category:Maharlika Pilipinas Basketball League roster navigational boxes merge (non-admin closure ) March 2
Category:Major League Soccer first round draft picks delete soccer , but keep NHL March 26
Category:Male characters in television keep March 9
Category:Manned missions to Mars rename per Talk:Human mission to Mars#Requested_move_5_March_2018 March 5
Category:Manned Soyuz missions rename March 5
Category:Manned spacecraft rename March 5
Category:Marshmello delete (non-admin closure ) March 15
Category:MCU actors moot . Speedy-deleted by @Bbb23 per WP:G5 (Creation by a blocked or banned user in violation of block or ban)March 20
Category:Medieval Samaritan physicians upmerge to three parent categories (non-admin closure ) March 1
Category:Mega-City One people upmerge (non-admin closure ) March 13
Category:Members of the Election Committee of Hong Kong, 2000–2005 nomination withdrawn March 14
Mergers and acquisitions by year
rename March 12
Category:Ministry of Catering (Jordan) Delete (WP:NAC ). --March 24
Category:Misha Arobelidze delete (non-admin closure ) March 29
Category:Modern Turkic states relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Modern_Turkic_states March 17
Category:Monsters keep as a parent categoryMarch 25
Category:Monsters split relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 4
Category:Muscovy Company delete , without prejudice to recreating the category if and when there are more pages to populate itMarch 16
Category:Non-commercial use only images relisted, see here March 11
Category:Non-governmental organisations with Irish names keep . At least based on this poorly conceived nominationMarch 28
Category:Non-governmental organization stubs no consensus . There might have been consensus for a merge, but there is no consensus for outright deletionMarch 21
Category:Non-governmental organizations of elected officials in Nigeria merge to Category:Political organizations in Nigeria . One is stated to be non-partisan so I have also added it into Category:Government-related professional associations . –March 28
Category:Non-governmental organizations of elected officials in the United States rename to Category:Government-related professional associations in the United States March 28
Category:Nothing relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Nothing March 20
Category:Now United delete (non-admin closure ) March 15
Category:Nullary operations delete March 13
Category:Olympic javelin throwers keep (non-admin closure ) March 5
Category:OM Merge , without redirectMarch 21
Category:Operas set in Iberia merge articles to Category:Operas set in Spain , but sub-categories must be merged to Category:Operas set in Europe . –March 11
Category:Operas set in Scandinavia delete by merging to Category:Operas set in Europe , because at the time of closure it only contains sub-categories and those are not directly in that parent. –March 12
Category:Orders, decorations, and medals no consensus (non-admin closure ) March 29
Category:Organizations based in Antarctica relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Organizations_based_in_Antarctica March 27
Category:OTI Festival Venues delete (non-admin closure ) March 22
Category:Pages with incorrect dash length in scorelines delete (non-admin closure ) March 15
Category:Parkway Drive delete (non-admin closure ) March 30
Category:Peers by year rename . –March 29
Category:People from Appalachia by county delete March 1
Category:People from Tonnerre rename (non-admin closure ) March 5
Category:People of Cuman descent delete Category:Ukrainian people of Cuman descent , but keep Category:People of Cuman descent March 24
Category:Places on the Juan Bautista de Anza National Historic Trail delete March 3
Category:Plants containing caffeine merge to Category:Herbal and fungal stimulants . (non-admin closure ) March 6
Category:Player progress tracking in video games relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 25
Category:Polaris people delete (non-admin closure ) March 8
Political prisoners
delete (non-admin closure ) March 11
Political prisoners
relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 2
Category:Prague linguistic circle keep March 2
Category:Presidents of the University of Santiago, Chile Student Federation merge (non-admin closure ) March 11
Category:Procurement practices merge . The category currently has only two other specific sub-categories, not 30 as mentioned by the editor who objected, and he has not replied to the nominator's point about inclusion criteria. –March 29
Category:Professional wrestling jobbers relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Professional_wrestling_jobbers March 1
Category:Province of Venice relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:Province_of_Venice March 1
Category:Psychiatry organizations keep March 11
Category:Quezon City Capitals templates delete (non-admin closure ) March 2
Category:Racehorse births by year rename March 1
Category:Racehorse births merge March 1
Category:Radio stations in West Edmonton Mall delete (non-admin closure ) March 13
Category:Railway accidents rename (non-admin closure ) March 16
Category:Railway stations at college campuses rename . There is a consensus that if the category is kept, it should be renamed. No consensus on @Marcocapelle and DexDor 's suggestion to delete, so feel free to open a new deletion discussion on the renamed categoryMarch 27
Category:Roku software delete (non-admin closure ) March 31
Category:Roman Catholic cleric-scientists rename . –March 13
Category:Roman Catholic orders and societies merge . –March 13
Category:Roman Catholic universities and colleges relisted at 2018 May 3 . –March 13
Category:Roman Catholicism and science rename , which will now also match the article after the RM linked below. –March 13
Category:Rougetius delete as empty (non-admin closure ) March 7
Category:S.League rename all March 23
Category:Scheduling class delete March 4
Category:Science ministries merge March 26
Category:Scottish devolution not renamed March 13
Category:Scottish devolution withdrawn (non-admin closure ) March 9
Category:Secretary-General no consensus . A nomination to merge might have had a different outcomeMarch 26
Category:Serjeants-at-law Rename (WP:NAC )March 22
Category:SESAC relisted, see here March 23
Category:SESAC soft delete (non-admin closure ) March 31
Category:Simplification relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Simplification March 8
Category:Social Democratic Party (UK) MEPs keep March 13
Category:Somali-born male long-distance runners selectively merge March 8
Category:Songs about Libanon speedy deleted as an empty category. There's no need for seven days of debate about a straightforward spelling error that the creator caught and corrected themself, when it can just be speedy deleted under at least two criteria (empty category and/or "Author requests deletion")March 23
Category:Songs written by Takeoff (rapper) no consensus March 11
Category:Specialist law enforcement agencies of Republic of Macedonia rename (non-admin closure ) March 24
Category:Specialist police agencies of India relisted, see here (non-admin closure ) March 24
Category:Sports competitors no action ; a different proposal may be brought forward instead. –March 24
Category:Sportspeople who were artists delete . List is at List of sportspeople–artists March 24
Category:Sportspeople procedural close . The nom withdrew the original proposal, at which point this discussion should have been closed. Trying to use this discussion as the place for a different proposal involving different categories just makes a confused discussion. Feel free to open a new discussion about the new proposalMarch 17
Category:Strigeidida relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2018_April_10#Category:Strigeidida March 23
Category:Tatar topics relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:Tatar_topics March 25
Category:Television anchors from Lafayette, Indiana delete (non-admin closure ) March 27
Television programmes
rename all except Canada and Australia March 24
Template:Southern-California-geo-stub
relisted, see here . (non-admin closure ) March 26
Category:Tennis players from Indiana Merge March 18
Category:TERF violence delete . CFD wasn't even really necessary, as empty categories can just be speedied so long as they weren't emptied out of process, but we are where we areMarch 13
Category:Tomb Raider series no consensus March 25
Category:Tomb Raider series relisted, see here March 17
Category:Tourist attraction in Sylhet rename (non-admin closure ) March 4
Category:Tower Hamlets Independent Group councillors keep . Delete !voters far outnumber keep !voters, but the nominator's blatant misrepresentation of WP:SMALLCAT was accepted by most keep !voters, leaving their !votes ill-founded in policy. For the record, WP:SMALLCAT 's current version says Avoid categories that, by their very definition, will never have more than a few members, unless such categories are part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme (underlining added by me) March 11
Category:Trade and professional organizations merge March 19
Category:Trick 'r Treat Delete (No prejudice against recreation in the future if this ever actually does turn into an ongoing franchise) (WP:NAC ). March 30
Tsardom of Russia
no consensus March 16
Category:Turkic tribes split March 21
Category:Turkmenistan dentists keep without prejudice against opening a fresh discussion with a batch nomination. (non-admin closure ) March 11
Category:Ukrainian Cossack nobility relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Ukrainian Cossack nobility March 11
Category:Ukrainian Cossack officers delete March 10
Category:Ukrainian military personnel of the Khmelnytsky Uprising rename March 18
Category:Ukrainian people of the Thirty Years' War Merge March 18
Category:Unary operations relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Unary_operations March 13
Category:Universal Deluxe Editions delete March 29
Category:Veritas (political party) MEPs keep March 13
Category:Video game locations relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Video game locations March 8
Category:Videographies of YouTubers no consensus March 23
Category:Viking Age in Scotland relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 10#Category:Viking_Age_in_Scotland March 18
Category:Washington Senators (1961–1971) personnel merge to Category:Washington Senators (MLB 1961–1971) . (non-admin closure ) March 11
Category:We Demand a Referendum Now politicians keep . WP:INVOLVED . However, this discussion is ~30 days overdue for closure, and consensus is clear, so I think that Wikipedia is better served by closing it.March 13
Category:West Edmonton Mall delete . (non-admin closure ) March 13
Category:Wild Arms (series) rename all March 15
Category:Women Tech Executives split (non-admin closure ) . @Swpb and Dimadick : It would be great if one of you could perform the split and let me know when you are done. In any case I'll list this at WP:CFDWM March 26
Category:Women video bloggers keep March 24
Years and decades in Russia
merge year categories in Russia before 1547 to century categories in Russia and to Europe categories. This consensus is without prejudice to further discussions. –March 1
Years and decades in Ukraine
merge up to 17th century, no consensus for 1700s onwards. –March 4
Category:Yoruba-speaking people relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 13#Category:Yoruba-speaking people March 16
Category:YouTubers by genre no consensus March 23
Category:Yusuf Islam albums speedy keep per WP:SNOW . (non-admin closure ) March 13
Category:Zaporozhian Cossacks relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 April 12#Category:Zaporozhian Cossacks March 11
